Doctor Who/Recap/S17/E06 Shada: Difference between revisions

Content added Content deleted

Inline

Latest revision as of 18:35, 15 April 2018

The Doctor: When I was on the river, I heard a strange babble of inhuman voices. Didn't you, Romana?
Romana: Yes.
Professor Chronotis: Oh, undergraduates talking to each other, I expect. I've tried to have it banned.

Filming on Shada ("SHAH-duh"), which was interrupted by the 1979 BBC strike, was never completed. It remains the only story of Classic Who that has never aired. But Douglas Adams scripts aren't so common that they can be discarded so easily, and eventually four official versions saw the light of day: a 1992 filmed version cobbled together out of the existing bits, with linking narration provided by Tom Baker; a 2003 Big Finish-produced audio/web-animation version with Eighth Doctor Paul McGann as the story's Doctor; a 2012 novelisation by Gareth Roberts, based on the final versions of the scripts; and at last a 2017 direct-to-video release of the original story with animation filling in the missing pieces and a bonus scene at the very end. Clips from this episode were also used in "The Five Doctors".

For extra credit, spot the plot elements that Adams recycled into Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency.

The Doctor and Romana drop by St. Cedd's College, Cambridge, in 1979, to visit Professor Chronotis, a retired Time Lord posing as an eccentric old Cambridge don. Chronotis is extremely old, even for a Time Lord, which makes his memory spotty and unreliable... but after some gentle prompting, he eventually remembers that he'd wanted the Doctor to take a certain book back to Gallifrey. No ordinary book, this, but an ancient relic from the days of Rassilon, the founder of Time Lord society, and possibly (read: almost certainly) full of uncertain and dangerous powers. The three Time Lords begin to search Chronotis' flat for it.

Unfortunately, Chronotis has already forgotten that he'd just that morning lent it out to physics student Chris Parsons—who's taken his new toy over to the lab to examine it, with baffled fascination, and even asked his girlfriend Claire to come have a look.

Even more unfortunately, someone else is after the book, too: a guy named Skagra, and with a name like that he's got to be evil. Skagra's putting the finishing touches on a brain-inna-jar—actually, a collection of great minds, whom he'd lured into working with him under false pretenses and then mind-napped—and just needs one more mind. Specifically, he wants the mind of legendary Time Lord criminal Salyavin, who was said to have the power to project his own mind into other minds; with this power in Skagra's brain jar, he'd be able to control the rest of the universe. Salyavin is imprisoned on the prison planet of Shada, whose location has been lost for centuries, but Skagra is convinced that the directions are in Chronotis' book.

By the time Chronotis remembers Chris Parsons' name, Skagra has parked his spaceship outside town and gotten a lift to St Cedd's. The Doctor's just left, though—he's borrowed a bike and gone off to fetch Chris from the physics lab, little realizing that the guy he nearly crashed into on the way was Chris himself, on his way to see Chronotis to ask about the book.

The Doctor does meet Claire at the lab; with her in tow, and in possession of the book, they return to Chronotis' flat—to find the old professor dead, killed by Skagra while Romana was in the TARDIS looking for milk for the tea.

Tropes used in "Shada" include:

Actually, I Am Him
Assimilation Plot: "The Universe, Doctor, as you so crudely put it, will not be mine, the Universe will be me!"
Brain In a Jar
Everyone Knows Morse: Although in this case it's Gallifreyan Morse.
Gone Horribly Right: The Doctor convinces the computer that he's dead and a dead enemy ain't an enemy no more. However, "dead men do not require oxygen."
Grand Theft Me
Ham-to-Ham Combat: Paul McGann vs Andrew Sachs, in the Big Finish audio version. It's rather rather magnificent.
Heel Face Turn: Salyavin, aka Professor Chronotis.
Insane Troll Logic: The Doctor convincing the ship's computer that he is dead "in a fabulous display of illogic logic" in order to get it to release Chris and K-9.
Letting Her Hair Down: Claire
Literal-Minded: Neither rhetorical questions nor expletives are a particularly good idea around K-9.
MacGuffin: the book
Oxbridge: Fictional Cedd's College in actual Cambridge.
Penal Colony: Shada itself
Silicon-Based Life: The Kraags, probably.
Spot of Tea
What We Now Know to Be True:

The Doctor: What? Do you understand Einstein?
Parsons: Yes.
The Doctor: What? And quantum theory?
Parsons: Yes.
The Doctor: What? And Planck?
Parsons: Yes.
The Doctor: What? And Newton?
Parsons: Yes.
The Doctor: What? And Schoenberg?

Parsons: Of course.

The Doctor: You've got a lot to unlearn.

SHAAAAADAAAAAA!!

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 {{work}}
-[[File:romanaboat_9888.jpg|frame|1979]]
+[[File:romanaboat_9888.jpg|thumb|300px|1979]]
 {{quote|'''The Doctor:''' When I was on the river, I heard a strange babble of inhuman voices. Didn't you, Romana?
 '''Romana:''' Yes.
 '''Professor Chronotis:''' Oh, undergraduates talking to each other, I expect. I've tried to have it banned. }}
-Filming on ''Shada'' ("SHAH-duh"), which was interrupted by the 1979 BBC strike, was never completed. It remains the only story of Classic Who that has never aired. But [[Douglas Adams]] scripts aren't so common that they can be discarded so easily, and eventually ''three'' official versions saw the light of day: a 1992 filmed version cobbled together out of the existing bits, with linking narration provided by [[Tom Baker]]; a 2003 [[Big Finish]]-produced audio/web-animation [http://www.bbc.co.uk/doctorwho/classic/webcasts/shada/ version] with Eighth Doctor Paul McGann as the story's Doctor; and a 2012 novelisation by Gareth Roberts, based on the final versions of the scripts. Clips from this episode were also used in "[[Doctor Who/20th AS the Five Doctors/Recap|The Five Doctors]]".
+Filming on ''Shada'' ("SHAH-duh"), which was interrupted by the 1979 BBC strike, was never completed. It remains the only story of Classic Who that has never aired. But [[Douglas Adams]] scripts aren't so common that they can be discarded so easily, and eventually ''four'' official versions saw the light of day: a 1992 filmed version cobbled together out of the existing bits, with linking narration provided by [[Tom Baker]]; a 2003 [[Big Finish]]-produced audio/web-animation [http://www.bbc.co.uk/doctorwho/classic/webcasts/shada/ version] with Eighth Doctor Paul McGann as the story's Doctor; a 2012 novelisation by Gareth Roberts, based on the final versions of the scripts; and at last a 2017 direct-to-video release of the original story with animation filling in the missing pieces and a bonus scene at the very end. Clips from this episode were also used in "[[Doctor Who/Recap/20th AS the Five Doctors|The Five Doctors]]".
 For extra credit, spot the plot elements that Adams recycled into ''[[Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency]]''.
@@ Line 14: / Line 14: @@
 The Doctor and Romana drop by St. Cedd's College, Cambridge, in 1979, to visit Professor Chronotis, a retired Time Lord posing as an eccentric old Cambridge don. Chronotis is extremely old, even for a Time Lord, which makes his memory spotty and unreliable... but after some gentle prompting, he eventually remembers that he'd wanted the Doctor to take a certain book back to Gallifrey. No ''ordinary'' book, this, but an ancient relic from the days of Rassilon, the founder of Time Lord society, and possibly (read: almost certainly) full of uncertain and dangerous powers. The three Time Lords begin to search Chronotis' flat for it.
-Unfortunately, Chronotis has already forgotten that he'd just that morning lent it out to physics student Chris Parsons--who's taken his new toy over to the lab to examine it, with baffled fascination, and even asked his girlfriend Claire to come have a look.
+Unfortunately, Chronotis has already forgotten that he'd just that morning lent it out to physics student Chris Parsons—who's taken his new toy over to the lab to examine it, with baffled fascination, and even asked his girlfriend Claire to come have a look.
-Even ''more'' unfortunately, someone else is after the book, too: a guy named Skagra, and with a name like that he's ''got'' to be evil. Skagra's putting the finishing touches on a brain-inna-jar--actually, a collection of great minds, whom he'd lured into working with him under false pretenses and then mind-napped--and just needs one more mind. Specifically, he wants the mind of legendary Time Lord criminal Salyavin, who was said to have the power to project his own mind into other minds; with this power in Skagra's brain jar, he'd be able to control the rest of the universe. Salyavin is imprisoned on the prison planet of Shada, whose location has been lost for centuries, but Skagra is convinced that the directions are in Chronotis' book.
+Even ''more'' unfortunately, someone else is after the book, too: a guy named Skagra, and with a name like that he's ''got'' to be evil. Skagra's putting the finishing touches on a brain-inna-jar—actually, a collection of great minds, whom he'd lured into working with him under false pretenses and then mind-napped—and just needs one more mind. Specifically, he wants the mind of legendary Time Lord criminal Salyavin, who was said to have the power to project his own mind into other minds; with this power in Skagra's brain jar, he'd be able to control the rest of the universe. Salyavin is imprisoned on the prison planet of Shada, whose location has been lost for centuries, but Skagra is convinced that the directions are in Chronotis' book.
-By the time Chronotis remembers Chris Parsons' name, Skagra has parked his spaceship outside town and gotten a lift to St Cedd's. The Doctor's just left, though--he's borrowed a bike and gone off to fetch Chris from the physics lab, little realizing that the guy he nearly crashed into on the way was Chris himself, on ''his'' way to see Chronotis to ask about the book.
+By the time Chronotis remembers Chris Parsons' name, Skagra has parked his spaceship outside town and gotten a lift to St Cedd's. The Doctor's just left, though—he's borrowed a bike and gone off to fetch Chris from the physics lab, little realizing that the guy he nearly crashed into on the way was Chris himself, on ''his'' way to see Chronotis to ask about the book.
-The Doctor does meet Claire at the lab; with her in tow, and in possession of the book, they return to Chronotis' flat--to find the old professor dead, killed by Skagra while Romana was in the TARDIS looking for milk for the tea.
+The Doctor does meet Claire at the lab; with her in tow, and in possession of the book, they return to Chronotis' flat—to find the old professor dead, killed by Skagra while Romana was in the TARDIS looking for milk for the tea.
+{{tropelist|Tropes used in "Shada" include:}}
-=== Tropes ===
 * [[Actually, I Am Him]]
@@ Line 32: / Line 32: @@
 * [[Ham-to-Ham Combat]]: Paul McGann vs Andrew Sachs, in the [[Big Finish]] audio version. It's rather [[Crowning Moment of Funny|rather magnificent]].
 * [[Heel Face Turn]]: Salyavin, aka Professor Chronotis.
 * [[Insane Troll Logic]]: The Doctor convincing the ship's computer that he is dead "in a fabulous display of illogic logic" in order to get it to release Chris and K-9.
 * [[Letting Her Hair Down]]: Claire
-* [[Literal Minded]]: Neither rhetorical questions nor expletives are a particularly good idea around K-9.
+* [[Literal-Minded]]: Neither rhetorical questions nor expletives are a particularly good idea around K-9.
 * [[MacGuffin]]: the book
 * [[Oxbridge]]: Fictional Cedd's College in actual Cambridge.
@@ Line 40: / Line 40: @@
 * [[Silicon-Based Life]]: The Kraags, probably.
 * [[Spot of Tea]]
 * [[What We Now Know to Be True]]:
 {{quote|'''The Doctor''': What? Do you understand Einstein?
 '''Parsons''': Yes.