Remove the Head or Destroy the Brain: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
("Zombie & Mummy" is a web comic and inappropriate as a link here; added examples, added categories)
(Big ups for the help, LT)
Line 3: Line 3:
{{tropestub}}
{{tropestub}}


A trope commonly associated with zombies and mummies as well as other forms of undead - to put down the creature for good, or else render it far more vulnerable, you usually have to '''Remove the Head or Destroy the Brain'''. [[Truth in Television|The head and brain are logical targets]] for disabling or killing an enemy, be they living or otherwise - after all, they're basically the cockpit a majority of living thing pilot their meat suit of a body from.
A trope commonly associated with [[Everything's Deader with Zombies|zombies]] and [[Mummy|mummies]], as well as other forms of undead - to put down the creature for good, or else render it far more vulnerable, you usually have to '''Remove the Head or Destroy the Brain'''. [[Truth in Television|The head and brain are logical targets]] for disabling or killing an enemy, be they living or otherwise - after all, they're basically the cockpit a majority of living thing pilot their meat suit of a body from. The trope also applies to some living and ''nonliving'' beings as well - many [[Humanoid Aliens]] and constructs that are especially durable may operate on similar logic, [[Most Writers Are Human|which only makes sense]].


But what makes this subtrope of [[Attack Its Weak Point]] different from other examples - and what makes it more than just [[Losing Your Head]] - is the implication that nothing else will do the job: take off a zombie's legs and it'll drag itself after you; take off the arms, and it'll still try to worm its way towards you. Even dismemberment may not cut it completely - as long as the head's still around, that undead monster will still be moaning and groaning as it hops or rolls in your general direction, and it may or may not be joined by the rest of its body parts... but once you pulp that noggin, its remains will promptly go inert and wither away. Hopefully.
But what makes this subtrope of [[Attack Its Weak Point]] different from other examples - and what makes it more than just [[Losing Your Head]] - is the implication that nothing else will do the job: take off a zombie's legs and it'll drag itself after you; take off the arms, and it'll still try to worm its way towards you. Even dismemberment may not cut it completely - as long as the head's still around, that undead monster will still be moaning and groaning as it hops or rolls in your general direction, and it may or may not be joined by the rest of its body parts... but once you pulp that noggin, its remains will promptly go inert and wither away. Hopefully.


The trope also applies to some living and ''nonliving'' beings as well - some humanoid aliens and constructs that are especially durable may operate on similar logic, [[Most Writers Are Human|which only makes sense]]; other beings undead and otherwise can also subvert this, however. [[Skeletons]] are common candidates among the undead for subverting and playing this straight, and whether robots are still able to function on some level without their head attached [[Depending on the Writer|depends on who's writing.]] And of course, not every creature [[Bizarre Alien Biology|will have their brain in their ''head''.]]
Of course, beings undead and otherwise can also subvert this as well; [[Skeletons]] are common candidates among the undead both for subverting and playing this straight, and whether robots are still able to function on some level without their head attached [[Depending on the Writer|depends on who's writing.]] And of course there's always the [[Non-Human Undead]] and other similar [[Hybrid Monsters]] - and not every creature [[Bizarre Alien Biology|will have their brain in their ''head'']], after all.


Using this to dispatch [[Multiple Head Case]]s has varying results, depending on how much the heads control the body. Some are sufficiently disabled with the removal of one head, while more persistent types may require the removal of all of them - and then there's the [[Hydra Problem]]...
Using this to dispatch [[Multiple Head Case]]s has varying results, depending on how much the heads control the body. Some are sufficiently disabled with the removal of one head, while more persistent types may require the removal of all of them - and then there's the [[Hydra Problem]]...
Line 18: Line 18:


== [[Anime]] and [[Manga]] ==
== [[Anime]] and [[Manga]] ==
* While the Namekians of the ''[[Dragon Ball]]'' series can be killed like any other [[Humanoid Alien]], they possess a highly potent regeneration factor that lets them regrow lost limbs; Piccolo in particular states during the Buu Saga that he can regenerate from nearly anything as long as his head isn't damaged,<ref>Good thing too considering he had just recovered from being [[Taken for Granite]] and then [[Literally Shattered Lives|accidentally broken]] by Kid Trunks.</ref> which presumably applies to the rest of his people.
* While the Namekians of the ''[[Dragon Ball]]'' series can be killed like any other being, they possess a highly potent regeneration factor that lets them regrow lost limbs; Piccolo in particular states during the Buu Saga that he can regenerate from nearly anything as long as his head isn't damaged,<ref>Good thing too considering he had just recovered from being [[Taken for Granite]] and then [[Literally Shattered Lives|accidentally broken]] by Kid Trunks.</ref> which presumably applies to the rest of his people.
* The cores of the Angels in ''[[Neon Genesis Evangelion]]'' may not function ''neurologically'' as brains, but are effectively so for the purposes of this trope -- until the core is destroyed an Angel has effectively unlimited regeneration and can come back from almost any damage.
* The cores of the Angels in ''[[Neon Genesis Evangelion]]'' may not function ''neurologically'' as brains, but are effectively so for the purposes of this trope -- until the core is destroyed, an Angel has effectively unlimited regeneration and can come back from almost any damage.


== [[Child Ballad|Ballads]] ==
== [[Child Ballad|Ballads]] ==
Line 67: Line 67:


==[[Video Games]]==
==[[Video Games]]==
* [[The Legend of Zelda (Franchise)|''The Legend of Zelda'']] has many a creature that can only be thwarted with the removal of its head, including several skeletal enemies (whose names usually include the prefix "Stal-"):
* [[The Legend of Zelda (Franchise)|''The Legend of Zelda'']] has many a creature that can only be thwarted with the removal of its head, including several [[Dem Bones|skeletal enemies]] (whose names usually include the prefix "Stal-"):
** ''[[Zelda II: The Adventure of Link]]'' has the Geldarm, large centipede-like insects that block Link's path in desert levels; to defeat them, the player must attack their body, then strike at the head a few times as they lower to Link's height.
** ''[[Zelda II: The Adventure of Link]]'' has the Geldarm, large centipede-like insects that block Link's path in desert levels; the player must attack their body, then strike at the head a few times as they lower to Link's height to defeat them.
** Big Babas in ''[[Twilight Princess]]'' are carnivorous plants that share symbiotic relationships with Deku Likes, acting as the head to their body; the latter can only be defeated by first killing the Big Baba, which allows the player to plant a bomb inside the Deku Like.
** Big Babas in ''[[Twilight Princess]]'' are carnivorous plants that share symbiotic relationships with Deku Likes, acting as the head to their body; the latter can only be defeated by first killing the Big Baba, which allows the player to plant a bomb inside the Deku Like.
** The Stalfos of ''[[The Wind Waker]]'' will crumble if struck enough times, leaving their head to hop around until their body either regenerates or the player hits their head enough; smashing their head with the [[Drop the Hammer|Skull Hammer]] can defeat them instantly; Stalfos Knights in ''[[Cadence of Hyrule]]'' function similarly, though destroying the body's remains after collapsing them also works. This also applies to Stalchampion from ''[[Tri Force Heroes]]'', who is reduced to a disembodied skull during its final phase.
** The Stalfos of ''[[The Wind Waker]]'' will crumble if struck enough times, leaving their head to hop around until their body either regenerates or the player hits it enough times; smashing their head with the [[Drop the Hammer|Skull Hammer]] will defeat them instantly. Stalfos Knights in ''[[Cadence of Hyrule]]'' function similarly, though destroying the body's remains after collapsing them also works. This also applies to Stalchampion from ''[[Tri Force Heroes]]'', who is reduced to a disembodied skull during its final phase.
* ''[[Nethack]]'':
* ''[[Nethack]]'':
** The Vorpal Blade of ''Jabberwocky'' fame has a 5% chance to [[One-Hit Kill|behead the victim]] upon hitting them, [[No Sell|unless they have no head or else are intangible]] (e.g. ghosts, shades and vortices). This even includes nonliving monsters and multiheaded monsters such as ettins - of course, [[Yet Another Stupid Death|this also applies to '''you''']] if you're caught on the wrong end, which is a very likely danger in the Astral Plane. [[The Dev Team Thinks of Everything/NetHack|And yes, it always works against jabberwocks]].
** The Vorpal Blade of ''Jabberwocky'' fame has a 5% chance to [[One-Hit Kill|behead the victim]] upon hitting them, [[No Sell|unless they have no head or else are intangible]] (e.g. ghosts, shades and vortices). This even includes nonliving monsters and multiheaded monsters such as ettins - of course, [[Yet Another Stupid Death|this also applies to '''you''']] if you're caught on the wrong end, which is a very likely danger in the Astral Plane. [[The Dev Team Thinks of Everything/NetHack|And yes, it always works against jabberwocks]].
** The vorpal jabberwock is a [[Dummied Out|deferred monster]] in the vanilla game based on the jabberwock; variants that make use of it, such as ''[[GruntHack]]'' and ''[[UnNetHack]]'', often give the monster its ''own'' beheading attacks, though it retains the weakness to Vorpal Blade.
** The vorpal jabberwock is a [[Dummied Out|deferred monster]] in the vanilla game based on the jabberwock; variants that make use of it, such as ''[[GruntHack]]'' and ''[[UnNetHack]]'', often give the monster its ''own'' beheading attacks, though it retains the weakness to Vorpal Blade.
** While ''possibly'' not literal, [[Too Dumb To Live|brainlessness]] can result from being hit by one too many brain-eating attacks by a mind flayer, which reduces your intelligence - not only is this also an instadeath [[Stat Death|if your INT drops too low]], but even {{spoiler|[[Auto Revive|an amulet of life saving]]}} won't work properly, since [[Deader Than Dead|your brain will still be gone after.]]
** While ''possibly'' not literal, brainlessness can result from being hit by one too many brain-eating attacks by a mind flayer, which reduces your intelligence - not only is this also an instadeath [[Stat Death|if your INT drops too low]], but even {{spoiler|[[Auto Revive|an amulet of life saving]]}} won't work properly, since [[Deader Than Dead|your brain will still be gone after.]] {{spoiler|On the other hand, you can also polymorph into a mind flayer and inflict ''this'' to non-mindless enemies.}}


==[[Visual Novel]]s==
==[[Visual Novel]]s==

Revision as of 03:10, 1 December 2020

A trope commonly associated with zombies and mummies, as well as other forms of undead - to put down the creature for good, or else render it far more vulnerable, you usually have to Remove the Head or Destroy the Brain. The head and brain are logical targets for disabling or killing an enemy, be they living or otherwise - after all, they're basically the cockpit a majority of living thing pilot their meat suit of a body from. The trope also applies to some living and nonliving beings as well - many Humanoid Aliens and constructs that are especially durable may operate on similar logic, which only makes sense.

But what makes this subtrope of Attack Its Weak Point different from other examples - and what makes it more than just Losing Your Head - is the implication that nothing else will do the job: take off a zombie's legs and it'll drag itself after you; take off the arms, and it'll still try to worm its way towards you. Even dismemberment may not cut it completely - as long as the head's still around, that undead monster will still be moaning and groaning as it hops or rolls in your general direction, and it may or may not be joined by the rest of its body parts... but once you pulp that noggin, its remains will promptly go inert and wither away. Hopefully.

Of course, beings undead and otherwise can also subvert this as well; Skeletons are common candidates among the undead both for subverting and playing this straight, and whether robots are still able to function on some level without their head attached depends on who's writing. And of course there's always the Non-Human Undead and other similar Hybrid Monsters - and not every creature will have their brain in their head, after all.

Using this to dispatch Multiple Head Cases has varying results, depending on how much the heads control the body. Some are sufficiently disabled with the removal of one head, while more persistent types may require the removal of all of them - and then there's the Hydra Problem...

One way to make a beheading stick is to make it explode and/or land a choice headshot. Successfully doing this can render someone Deader Than Dead.

Examples of Remove the Head or Destroy the Brain include:

Advertising

Anime and Manga

  • While the Namekians of the Dragon Ball series can be killed like any other being, they possess a highly potent regeneration factor that lets them regrow lost limbs; Piccolo in particular states during the Buu Saga that he can regenerate from nearly anything as long as his head isn't damaged,[1] which presumably applies to the rest of his people.
  • The cores of the Angels in Neon Genesis Evangelion may not function neurologically as brains, but are effectively so for the purposes of this trope -- until the core is destroyed, an Angel has effectively unlimited regeneration and can come back from almost any damage.

Ballads

Comic Books

Fan Works

Film

  • The only way to kill an Immortal from the Highlander film and TV franchise is to remove his head.

Literature

  • The titular Jabberwocky is dispatched this way in Lewis Carroll's poem; both the creature and the weapon that slew it have been referenced by many works and games since.

Live-Action TV

  • Some species of demon in Buffy the Vampire Slayer can only be killed by removing their heads. (And a few are completely unbothered by such a trivial injury.)

Music

New Media

Newspaper Comics

Oral Tradition, Folklore, Myths and Legends

Pinball

Podcasts

Professional Wrestling

Puppet Shows

Radio

Recorded and Stand Up Comedy

Tabletop Games

Theatre

Video Games

  • The Legend of Zelda has many a creature that can only be thwarted with the removal of its head, including several skeletal enemies (whose names usually include the prefix "Stal-"):
    • Zelda II: The Adventure of Link has the Geldarm, large centipede-like insects that block Link's path in desert levels; the player must attack their body, then strike at the head a few times as they lower to Link's height to defeat them.
    • Big Babas in Twilight Princess are carnivorous plants that share symbiotic relationships with Deku Likes, acting as the head to their body; the latter can only be defeated by first killing the Big Baba, which allows the player to plant a bomb inside the Deku Like.
    • The Stalfos of The Wind Waker will crumble if struck enough times, leaving their head to hop around until their body either regenerates or the player hits it enough times; smashing their head with the Skull Hammer will defeat them instantly. Stalfos Knights in Cadence of Hyrule function similarly, though destroying the body's remains after collapsing them also works. This also applies to Stalchampion from Tri Force Heroes, who is reduced to a disembodied skull during its final phase.
  • Nethack:

Visual Novels

Web Animation

Web Comics

Web Original

Western Animation

  • In the final season of Samurai Jack, Scaramouche manages to survive his defeat at Jack's hands as a head, and just barely manages to make it back to his master Aku in time with news that the samurai had lost his sword, which was enough to earn him his body back. Unfortunately, by the time they next encounter him, he's long recovered his sword; Aku's punishment is... rather apt.

Other Media

Real Life

  • Cockroaches are subject to popular claims of being able to live without their heads, potentially subverting this trope; however, their capacity for such is exaggerated, and the trait is by no means exclusive to them. That said, a cockroach's severed head can still survive and wave its antennae for several hours, while the body still demonstrates behaviors such as shock avoidance and escape behavior.
  1. Good thing too considering he had just recovered from being Taken for Granite and then accidentally broken by Kid Trunks.