United 93: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
m (Mass update links)
m (Mass update links)
Line 8: Line 8:
* [[Artistic License Physics]]: When the plane is moved from side to side, the actors roll accordingly - however when the plane is moved up and down, the actors don't move along with that. Simulating the weightlessness and things flying around the cabin can be expensive and/or dangerous to the actors.
* [[Artistic License Physics]]: When the plane is moved from side to side, the actors roll accordingly - however when the plane is moved up and down, the actors don't move along with that. Simulating the weightlessness and things flying around the cabin can be expensive and/or dangerous to the actors.
* [[Autobiographical Role]]: In line with the [[Faux Documentary]] method, several of the air-traffic controllers and military officers are played by professionals who do those jobs for a living.
* [[Autobiographical Role]]: In line with the [[Faux Documentary]] method, several of the air-traffic controllers and military officers are played by professionals who do those jobs for a living.
** Even more impressive is that they got [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ben_Sliney Ben Sliney] to re-enact his first day on the job.
** Even more impressive is that they got [[wikipedia:Ben Sliney|Ben Sliney]] to re-enact his first day on the job.
* [[Based on a True Story]]: Artistic license had to be used in regards to the specifics of events on the plane, but otherwise the entire movie is kosher.
* [[Based on a True Story]]: Artistic license had to be used in regards to the specifics of events on the plane, but otherwise the entire movie is kosher.
* [[Bias Steamroller]]: Many critics and audience members were soured on the whole movie by the [[Villainous Valor]].
* [[Bias Steamroller]]: Many critics and audience members were soured on the whole movie by the [[Villainous Valor]].
Line 21: Line 21:
* [[Family-Unfriendly Death|Family Unfriendly Deaths]]:
* [[Family-Unfriendly Death|Family Unfriendly Deaths]]:
** A passenger is stabbed in the neck and bleeds out.
** A passenger is stabbed in the neck and bleeds out.
** One of the terrorists is [[No Holds Barred Beatdown|beaten to death with a fire-extinguisher.]]
** One of the terrorists is [[No-Holds-Barred Beatdown|beaten to death with a fire-extinguisher.]]
* [[Faux Documentary]]
* [[Faux Documentary]]
* [[Fog of War]]: Confusion is the only constant in the movie - impressively, the narrative remains coherent.
* [[Fog of War]]: Confusion is the only constant in the movie - impressively, the narrative remains coherent.
Line 28: Line 28:
* [[Gory Discretion Shot]]: Averted
* [[Gory Discretion Shot]]: Averted
* [[Heroic BSOD]]: ''Everyone'' on the ground after United 175 smashed into the South Tower.
* [[Heroic BSOD]]: ''Everyone'' on the ground after United 175 smashed into the South Tower.
* [[Hey It's That Guy]]: [[Boston Legal|Christian Clemenson]] and [[Sledge Hammer|David]] [[In the Loop|Rasche]] are the most recognisable faces in the film.
* [[Hey, It's That Guy!]]: [[Boston Legal|Christian Clemenson]] and [[Sledge Hammer|David]] [[In the Loop|Rasche]] are the most recognisable faces in the film.
* [[Improvised Weapon]]
* [[Improvised Weapon]]
* [[Kill'Em All]]: Kind of [[All There Is to Know About "The Crying Game"|obvious, innit]]?
* [[Kill'Em All]]: Kind of [[All There Is to Know About "The Crying Game"|obvious, innit]]?
Line 67: Line 67:
[[Category:Films of the 2000s]]
[[Category:Films of the 2000s]]
[[Category:United 93]]
[[Category:United 93]]
[[Category:Trope]]

Revision as of 18:37, 25 January 2014

Written and directed by Paul Greengrass, United 93 was released into theatres five years after the September 11th attacks on the World Trade Center towers and the Pentagon to much critical acclaim. As You Know (we assume), the film is Based on a True Story. United 93 was one of the hijacked planes on 9/11; after the plane had been hijacked and word got out that the other hijacked planes had been crashed into the Twin Towers, the passengers rose up and took out the terrorists, leading to a Heroic Sacrifice when the plane crashed in a field in Pensylvania instead of its intended target, killing all aboard but doubtless saving many other lives. Greengrass approached the daunting challenge of retelling the events of the titular flight with the same cautious, apolitical tone with which he guided Bloody Sunday.

Using largely unknown actors and real professionals, the film was denounced as Too Soon by many, but lauded by many others as a gentle, much-needed catharsis. It plays out in Real Time across nearly two-hours and was filmed Faux Documentary style using separate isolated stages.


This movie contains examples of:

 "When was the last time we had a hijack?"

"It's been quite a while..."

  • Retirony: A variation in that he's taking a vacation, not a pension.

  "My anniversary's coming up - I'm taking my wife to London for a couple days."

  • Shown Their Work: All the inaccuracies of 9/11 were accurately portrayed. It is commendable that rather than stripping down the confusion to make things easier for an audience to follow, all of the misinformed pieces of information are out there, just as it was in real life. Different groups were referring to the wrong planes by the wrong numbers. There were differing reports on how many planes were out there. The news reported a fire on the National Mall when there was none.
  • Storming The Cockpit
  • Strawman European: There's a German fellow aboard who advocates that the passengers just let the terrorists do their task. When the passengers ignore him, he even goes so far as to shout a warning to the terrorists before being subdued by the passengers.
    • It's worth pointing out that while it might seem insane now, official policy on all airlines prior to 9-11 was that passengers should not interfere if there is a hijacking, under the assumption that if the hijackers intended to blow up the plane they'd have already done so, and dealing with hijackers should be left to professionals.
      • This is a real national/cultural divide. America has long had a firm policy against negotiating with criminals or terrorists. A number of European countries are entirely willing to negotiate in order to get hostages released. The result is that hostage situations in European usually end with negotiated releases. It's not unreasonable that a European would want to wait for a deal to be struck rather than everyone getting killed.
  • Villainous Breakdown