The Bard on Board: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
m (cleanup categories)
m (update links)
Line 2: Line 2:
[[William Shakespeare]] has created some of the most memorable works in the history of the English language. So when you're a struggling writer, trying to find a good plot, why not take one of his?
[[William Shakespeare]] has created some of the most memorable works in the history of the English language. So when you're a struggling writer, trying to find a good plot, why not take one of his?


A subtrope of [[Whole-Plot Reference]], and also of [[Setting Update]]. A lot of [[Recycled in Space]] would be these as well (especially the rash of <small>[[High School AU|IN HIGH SCHOOL!]]</small> films like ''[[Ten Things I Hate About You]]'' (''[[The Taming of the Shrew]]''), ''O'' (''[[Othello]]''), and ''[[She's the Man]]'' (''[[Twelfth Night]]''). Not to be confused with [[Shakespeare in Fiction]].
A subtrope of [[Whole-Plot Reference]], and also of [[Setting Update]]. A lot of [[Recycled in Space]] would be these as well (especially the rash of <small>[[High School AU|IN HIGH SCHOOL!]]</small> films like ''[[10 Things I Hate About You]]'' (''[[The Taming of the Shrew]]''), ''O'' (''[[Othello]]''), and ''[[She's the Man]]'' (''[[Twelfth Night]]''). Not to be confused with [[Shakespeare in Fiction]].


This trope only applies to works that follow the plot of a Shakespeare play, ''not'' to works using his characters or written as sequels. So ''[[Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead]]'', despite being made entirely of characters in ''Hamlet'', is not this. It would only be so if Rosencrantz was Guildenstern's evil uncle, who killed Rosencrantz's father...
This trope only applies to works that follow the plot of a Shakespeare play, ''not'' to works using his characters or written as sequels. So ''[[Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead]]'', despite being made entirely of characters in ''Hamlet'', is not this. It would only be so if Rosencrantz was Guildenstern's evil uncle, who killed Rosencrantz's father...
Line 17: Line 17:


== [[Henry IV]] ==
== [[Henry IV]] ==
* ''[[My Own Private Idaho]]'' -- The story of two hustlers on a journey to find peace and a long-lost mother, inspired by ''Henry IV, Parts 1 and 2''.
* ''[[My Own Private Idaho]]'' -- The story of two hustlers on a journey to find peace and a long-lost mother, inspired by ''Henry IV, Parts 1 and 2''.


== [[King Lear]] ==
== [[King Lear]] ==
* [[Akira Kurosawa]]'s ''[[Ran]]'' is an interesting case. He [[Word of God|said in an interview]] that he wrote a draft of the screenplay and showed it to a friend, who read it and said "Oh, it's ''King Lear''!", to which Kurosawa responded, "It's what?" After he read Lear, he edited ''Ran'' to match it more closely, and threw in some quotes.
* [[Akira Kurosawa]]'s ''[[Ran]]'' is an interesting case. He [[Word of God|said in an interview]] that he wrote a draft of the screenplay and showed it to a friend, who read it and said "Oh, it's ''King Lear''!", to which Kurosawa responded, "It's what?" After he read Lear, he edited ''Ran'' to match it more closely, and threw in some quotes.
* ''[[King Of Texas]]'' -- ''King Lear'' set on a ranch in the Old West.
* ''[[King Of Texas]]'' -- ''King Lear'' set on a ranch in the Old West.
* ''[[A Thousand Acres]]'' -- ''King Lear'' on a Midwestern American farm, where three daughters despise their abusive father.
* ''[[A Thousand Acres]]'' -- ''King Lear'' on a Midwestern American farm, where three daughters despise their abusive father.
* ''[[Harry And Tonto]]'' -- After his life-long New York City home is torn down, a retired schoolteacher makes a cross-country journey to visit his estranged children in this adaptation of ''King Lear''.
* ''[[Harry And Tonto]]'' -- After his life-long New York City home is torn down, a retired schoolteacher makes a cross-country journey to visit his estranged children in this adaptation of ''King Lear''.
* ''[[Moss Gown]]'' is a mix of "[[Cinderella (novel)|Cinderella]]" and ''[[King Lear]]'' with a [[Setting Update]] to the antebellum [[Sweet Home Alabama]].
* ''[[Moss Gown]]'' is a mix of "[[Cinderella (novel)|Cinderella]]" and ''[[King Lear]]'' with a [[Setting Update]] to the antebellum [[Sweet Home Alabama]].


Line 32: Line 32:
** ''[[Men Of Respect]]'' was a remake of the 1955 film ''[[Joe Mac Beth]]'', which also recast the original story with modern-day gangsters.
** ''[[Men Of Respect]]'' was a remake of the 1955 film ''[[Joe Mac Beth]]'', which also recast the original story with modern-day gangsters.
* ''[[The Lion King]]'' also borrows from Macbeth, with Scar being Macbeth and the hyenas being the band of assassins he hires. Though there is not much to go for.
* ''[[The Lion King]]'' also borrows from Macbeth, with Scar being Macbeth and the hyenas being the band of assassins he hires. Though there is not much to go for.
* The TOS ''[[Outer Limits]]'' episode "The Bellero Shield" takes some elements from ''Macbeth'' without following the plot exactly. The Lady Macbeth role is filled by [[Ambition Is Evil|the greedy, ambitious wife]] of an idealistic scientist. When a gentle alien accidentally winds up in the husband's lab, he becomes the equivalent to {{spoiler|Banquo's ghost; the wife kills him and tries to pass off his [[Imported Alien Phlebotinum]] as her husband's invention, only to learn that the alien is [[Not Quite Dead]].}}
* The TOS ''[[Outer Limits]]'' episode "The Bellero Shield" takes some elements from ''Macbeth'' without following the plot exactly. The Lady Macbeth role is filled by [[Ambition Is Evil|the greedy, ambitious wife]] of an idealistic scientist. When a gentle alien accidentally winds up in the husband's lab, he becomes the equivalent to {{spoiler|Banquo's ghost; the wife kills him and tries to pass off his [[Imported Alien Phlebotinum]] as her husband's invention, only to learn that the alien is [[Not Quite Dead]].}}


== [[A Midsummer Night's Dream|A Midsummer Nights Dream]] ==
== [[A Midsummer Night's Dream|A Midsummer Nights Dream]] ==
Line 41: Line 41:


== [[Othello]] ==
== [[Othello]] ==
* ''[[All Night Long]]'' -- An adaptation of ''Othello'' set in the contemporary London jazz scene.
* ''[[All Night Long]]'' -- An adaptation of ''Othello'' set in the contemporary London jazz scene.
* ''Othello'', a modern language adaptation of Othello that aired on BBC in 2001. John Othello, a cop promoted to police commissioner, is manipulated by his former partner Jago. Stars Eeamon Walker as Othello and [[Christopher Eccleston]] as Jago.
* ''Othello'', a modern language adaptation of Othello that aired on BBC in 2001. John Othello, a cop promoted to police commissioner, is manipulated by his former partner Jago. Stars Eeamon Walker as Othello and [[Christopher Eccleston]] as Jago.
* ''"O"'' -- Odin James(Mekhi Phifer) is the captain of his high school basketball team, while Hugo(Josh Hartnett) plots to undo his popularity.
* ''"O"'' -- Odin James(Mekhi Phifer) is the captain of his high school basketball team, while Hugo(Josh Hartnett) plots to undo his popularity.


== [[Romeo and Juliet]] ==
== [[Romeo and Juliet]] ==
* ''[[Gnomeo and Juliet]]'' [[Hangs a Lampshade]] on it in the introduction, where one of the gnomes mention that "this story has been retold. A lot."
* ''[[Gnomeo and Juliet]]'' [[Hangs a Lampshade]] on it in the introduction, where one of the gnomes mention that "this story has been retold. A lot."
** Not just that. Later in the movie, {{spoiler|a statue of Shakespeare himself shows up and talks over the story with the main character, Gnomeo. He even says, obliquely, that the original story was a tragedy and that he hopes Gnomeo's story ends on a happier note, setting Gnomeo further on his quest to make sure his story turns out differently}}.
** Not just that. Later in the movie, {{spoiler|a statue of Shakespeare himself shows up and talks over the story with the main character, Gnomeo. He even says, obliquely, that the original story was a tragedy and that he hopes Gnomeo's story ends on a happier note, setting Gnomeo further on his quest to make sure his story turns out differently}}.
* ''[[West Side Story]]'' is a modernized, musical version of ''Romeo and Juliet''.
* ''[[West Side Story]]'' is a modernized, musical version of ''Romeo and Juliet''.
Line 52: Line 52:
* ''[[Romeo Must Die]]'' -- Loosely based on ''Romeo and Juliet'' featuring Chinese and black mob families as the Montagues and Capulets and lots of kung fu.
* ''[[Romeo Must Die]]'' -- Loosely based on ''Romeo and Juliet'' featuring Chinese and black mob families as the Montagues and Capulets and lots of kung fu.
* ''[[Love Is All There Is]]'' -- ''Romeo and Juliet'' with two rival restaurant-owning Italian families in New York at constant odds especially after their children fall in love.
* ''[[Love Is All There Is]]'' -- ''Romeo and Juliet'' with two rival restaurant-owning Italian families in New York at constant odds especially after their children fall in love.
* ''[[China Girl]]'' -- ''Romeo and Juliet'' in New York City, with rival Italian and Chinese gangs as the feuding families.
* ''[[China Girl]]'' -- ''Romeo and Juliet'' in New York City, with rival Italian and Chinese gangs as the feuding families.
* ''[[William Shakespeare's Romeo+Juliet|William Shakespeares Romeo and Juliet]]''
* ''[[William Shakespeare's Romeo+Juliet|William Shakespeares Romeo and Juliet]]''
* ''[[The Lion King|The Lion King II: Simba's Pride]]'', when it comes to Kiara (Simba's daughter) and Kovu's forbidden romance.
* ''[[The Lion King|The Lion King II: Simba's Pride]]'', when it comes to Kiara (Simba's daughter) and Kovu's forbidden romance.
Line 58: Line 58:


== [[The Taming of the Shrew]] ==
== [[The Taming of the Shrew]] ==
* ''[[Ten Things I Hate About You]]'' is based on ''The Taming of the Shrew'', set in high school.
* ''[[10 Things I Hate About You]]'' is based on ''The Taming of the Shrew'', set in high school.
* ''[[Deliver Us From Eva]]'' -- Revolving around [[LL Cool J]]'s character Ray being paid to date a troublesome young lady named Eva. To some extent, it is a modern, urban update ''The Taming of the Shrew''.
* ''[[Deliver Us From Eva]]'' -- Revolving around [[LL Cool J]]'s character Ray being paid to date a troublesome young lady named Eva. To some extent, it is a modern, urban update ''The Taming of the Shrew''.


Line 70: Line 70:
* In the ''[[Twilight (novel)|Twilight]]'' Saga Official guide, Stephenie Mayer says that ''New Moon'' was inspired by ''[[Romeo and Juliet]]'' and ''Breaking Dawn'' by ''[[A Midsummer Night's Dream|A Midsummer Nights Dream]]'' and ''[[Othello]]''.
* In the ''[[Twilight (novel)|Twilight]]'' Saga Official guide, Stephenie Mayer says that ''New Moon'' was inspired by ''[[Romeo and Juliet]]'' and ''Breaking Dawn'' by ''[[A Midsummer Night's Dream|A Midsummer Nights Dream]]'' and ''[[Othello]]''.
* The Consul's Tale ("Remembering Siri") from ''[[Hyperion]]'' is a literary example.
* The Consul's Tale ("Remembering Siri") from ''[[Hyperion]]'' is a literary example.
* Simon Hawke wrote a [[Shakespeare in Fiction|series of books]] with a young Shakespeare and his buddy solving mysteries that bore a strong resemblance to Shakespeare's plays (which, [[In-Universe]], he wrote much later). The first one was called ''A Mystery Of Errors'' followed by ''Much Ado About Murder'', ''The Merchant of Vengence'', and ''The Slaying of the Shrew''.
* Simon Hawke wrote a [[Shakespeare in Fiction|series of books]] with a young Shakespeare and his buddy solving mysteries that bore a strong resemblance to Shakespeare's plays (which, [[In-Universe]], he wrote much later). The first one was called ''A Mystery Of Errors'' followed by ''Much Ado About Murder'', ''The Merchant of Vengence'', and ''The Slaying of the Shrew''.
* Also in-universe, in ''[[The Curse of Monkey Island]]'', a theatre performer on the pirate-infested Plunder Island rewrites a host of Shakespeare plays to better suit the local pirates' tastes, turning them into "Speare!", a revue of mishmashed Shakespeare plots with piratey undertones and new acrobatic stunts.
* Also in-universe, in ''[[The Curse of Monkey Island]]'', a theatre performer on the pirate-infested Plunder Island rewrites a host of Shakespeare plays to better suit the local pirates' tastes, turning them into "Speare!", a revue of mishmashed Shakespeare plots with piratey undertones and new acrobatic stunts.
* ''[[The Lion King|The Lion King 1 1/2]]'', which is essentially the first film, but told from Timon and Pumbaa's perspective.
* ''[[The Lion King|The Lion King 1 1/2]]'', which is essentially the first film, but told from Timon and Pumbaa's perspective.
** Therefore, since ''The Lion King'' is ''[[Hamlet]]'', ''The Lion King 1 1/2'' must be ''[[Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead]]'', which is surprisingly accurate given how both works poke at meta.
** Therefore, since ''The Lion King'' is ''[[Hamlet]]'', ''The Lion King 1 1/2'' must be ''[[Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead]]'', which is surprisingly accurate given how both works poke at meta.

Revision as of 22:00, 5 October 2014

William Shakespeare has created some of the most memorable works in the history of the English language. So when you're a struggling writer, trying to find a good plot, why not take one of his?

A subtrope of Whole-Plot Reference, and also of Setting Update. A lot of Recycled in Space would be these as well (especially the rash of IN HIGH SCHOOL! films like 10 Things I Hate About You (The Taming of the Shrew), O (Othello), and She's the Man (Twelfth Night). Not to be confused with Shakespeare in Fiction.

This trope only applies to works that follow the plot of a Shakespeare play, not to works using his characters or written as sequels. So Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead, despite being made entirely of characters in Hamlet, is not this. It would only be so if Rosencrantz was Guildenstern's evil uncle, who killed Rosencrantz's father... So Alan Gordon's Thirteenth Night (being a sequel to Twelfth Night) doesn't count, but his An Antic Disposition (which follows the plot of Hamlet) would.

Examples


Hamlet

  • The Lion King -- Evil uncle kills good king father, son overthrows him. The ending is a little lighter, though.
  • Akira Kurosawa's The Bad Sleep Well -- Young man gets a prominent position in a corrupt postwar Japanese company in order to expose the men responsible for his father's death. It has its roots in Hamlet.
  • Let The Devil Wear Black -- Hamlet updated to modern-day southern California as a moody grad student is compelled to take revenge on his uncle for his father's death.
  • Legend of the Black Scorpion is the wuxia version of Hamlet.
  • Strange Brew is a fairly low-brow version of Hamlet, with, perhaps, Bob and Doug McKenzie as Rosenkrantz and Guildenstern.
  • The Dead Fathers Club is a novel that reimagines the story of Hamlet in modern-day England.

Henry IV

  • My Own Private Idaho -- The story of two hustlers on a journey to find peace and a long-lost mother, inspired by Henry IV, Parts 1 and 2.

King Lear

  • Akira Kurosawa's Ran is an interesting case. He said in an interview that he wrote a draft of the screenplay and showed it to a friend, who read it and said "Oh, it's King Lear!", to which Kurosawa responded, "It's what?" After he read Lear, he edited Ran to match it more closely, and threw in some quotes.
  • King Of Texas -- King Lear set on a ranch in the Old West.
  • A Thousand Acres -- King Lear on a Midwestern American farm, where three daughters despise their abusive father.
  • Harry And Tonto -- After his life-long New York City home is torn down, a retired schoolteacher makes a cross-country journey to visit his estranged children in this adaptation of King Lear.
  • Moss Gown is a mix of "Cinderella" and King Lear with a Setting Update to the antebellum Sweet Home Alabama.

Macbeth

  • Akira Kurosawa's Throne of Blood was directly and consciously based on Macbeth.
  • Scotland, PA, which transplants Macbeth to a fast food restaurant in rural Pennsylvania in the 1970s.
  • Men Of Respect -- After hearing a prophecy, a hitman executes his superiors and rises to the head of a mob family with dire consequences.
  • The Lion King also borrows from Macbeth, with Scar being Macbeth and the hyenas being the band of assassins he hires. Though there is not much to go for.
  • The TOS Outer Limits episode "The Bellero Shield" takes some elements from Macbeth without following the plot exactly. The Lady Macbeth role is filled by the greedy, ambitious wife of an idealistic scientist. When a gentle alien accidentally winds up in the husband's lab, he becomes the equivalent to Banquo's ghost; the wife kills him and tries to pass off his Imported Alien Phlebotinum as her husband's invention, only to learn that the alien is Not Quite Dead.

A Midsummer Nights Dream

Othello

  • All Night Long -- An adaptation of Othello set in the contemporary London jazz scene.
  • Othello, a modern language adaptation of Othello that aired on BBC in 2001. John Othello, a cop promoted to police commissioner, is manipulated by his former partner Jago. Stars Eeamon Walker as Othello and Christopher Eccleston as Jago.
  • "O" -- Odin James(Mekhi Phifer) is the captain of his high school basketball team, while Hugo(Josh Hartnett) plots to undo his popularity.

Romeo and Juliet

  • Gnomeo and Juliet Hangs a Lampshade on it in the introduction, where one of the gnomes mention that "this story has been retold. A lot."
    • Not just that. Later in the movie, a statue of Shakespeare himself shows up and talks over the story with the main character, Gnomeo. He even says, obliquely, that the original story was a tragedy and that he hopes Gnomeo's story ends on a happier note, setting Gnomeo further on his quest to make sure his story turns out differently.
  • West Side Story is a modernized, musical version of Romeo and Juliet.
  • An in-universe example: In one episode of Higher Ground, the students practice and perform a play written by their classmate, which eerily follows the plot of Romeo and Juliet, despite the writer's claim that he's never read Shakespeare. In the end, of course, it turned out he had, but his friend tells him that it's not a problem copying Shakespeare; writers do it all the time.
  • Romeo Must Die -- Loosely based on Romeo and Juliet featuring Chinese and black mob families as the Montagues and Capulets and lots of kung fu.
  • Love Is All There Is -- Romeo and Juliet with two rival restaurant-owning Italian families in New York at constant odds especially after their children fall in love.
  • China Girl -- Romeo and Juliet in New York City, with rival Italian and Chinese gangs as the feuding families.
  • William Shakespeares Romeo and Juliet
  • The Lion King II: Simba's Pride, when it comes to Kiara (Simba's daughter) and Kovu's forbidden romance.
  • Magical Legend of the Leprechauns. Let's say the original Sheakespearean ending is thoroughly reversed.

The Taming of the Shrew

  • 10 Things I Hate About You is based on The Taming of the Shrew, set in high school.
  • Deliver Us From Eva -- Revolving around LL Cool J's character Ray being paid to date a troublesome young lady named Eva. To some extent, it is a modern, urban update The Taming of the Shrew.

The Tempest

Twelfth Night

Misc/Multiple

  • In the Twilight Saga Official guide, Stephenie Mayer says that New Moon was inspired by Romeo and Juliet and Breaking Dawn by A Midsummer Nights Dream and Othello.
  • The Consul's Tale ("Remembering Siri") from Hyperion is a literary example.
  • Simon Hawke wrote a series of books with a young Shakespeare and his buddy solving mysteries that bore a strong resemblance to Shakespeare's plays (which, In-Universe, he wrote much later). The first one was called A Mystery Of Errors followed by Much Ado About Murder, The Merchant of Vengence, and The Slaying of the Shrew.
  • Also in-universe, in The Curse of Monkey Island, a theatre performer on the pirate-infested Plunder Island rewrites a host of Shakespeare plays to better suit the local pirates' tastes, turning them into "Speare!", a revue of mishmashed Shakespeare plots with piratey undertones and new acrobatic stunts.
  • The Lion King 1 1/2, which is essentially the first film, but told from Timon and Pumbaa's perspective.
  • Several Merlin episodes are based on Shakespeare plots, most notably "Sweet Dreams", which is a Comedy of Errors type story in which a Love Potion goes awry. In "Goblin's Gold", Arthur ends up with donkey's ears, rather like Puck from A Midsummer Nights Dream.