Anime First: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
m (Mass update links)
(copyedit)
 
(9 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
Anime is usually based on manga, light novels, visual novels or video games. Occasionally there are exceptions.
Anime is usually based on manga, light novels, visual novels or video games. Occasionally there are exceptions.


Anime is always more risky than manga. Pretty much everyone has a manga specifically geared to their interest somewhere, and the largely black and white format of manga makes it cheaper to produce than even the average western comic book. Producing a show is much more expensive<ref>Even a cheaply done 12 episode anime can literally cost $US 1 Million to produce when all is said and done, and that's the cheap stuff</ref>. And while a lot of manga is made to be accessible and disposable, the demographics of TV watchers is different. This is the major reason anime is mostly populated by shounen and shoujo, as kids simply have more time. Meanwhile, [[Josei]] manga rarely ever gets made into anime, if reaching television at all.
Anime is always more risky than manga. Pretty much everyone has a manga specifically geared to their interest somewhere, and the largely black and white format of manga makes it cheaper to produce than even the average western comic book. Producing a show is much more expensive.<ref>Even a cheaply-done 12 episode anime can literally cost $US 1 Million to produce when all is said and done, and that's the cheap stuff. Mind you, the expensive shows such as ''[[Cowboy Bebop]]'' cost $US 1 Million per episode. The really high end stuff, like ''[[The Tale of the Princess Kaguya]]'', needs around ten million dollars for 20 minutes of animation.</ref> And while a lot of manga is made to be accessible and disposable, the demographics of TV watchers is different. This is the major reason anime is mostly populated by shounen and shoujo, as kids simply have more time. Meanwhile, [[Josei]] manga rarely ever gets made into anime, if reaching television at all.


Anime also requires voice actors and a hopefully decent animation budget. On the other hand, it's much easier to make a show based on a known money-generating property. Making a show suddenly becomes lucrative once you figure in things like new merchandise (character [[Image Song]] and soundtracks, most noticeably) which pays for the show. This is the main reason [[Bleached Underpants|H-games made into anime]] are the most successful financially and on the other extreme, why most [[Anime First]] shows for youngsters are explicitly [[Merchandise-Driven]]. [[Magical Girl]] and Mecha series in particular have a high chance of being [[Anime First]].
Anime also requires voice actors and a hopefully decent animation budget. On the other hand, it's much easier to make a show based on a known money-generating property. Making a show suddenly becomes lucrative once you figure in things like new merchandise (character [[Image Song]] and soundtracks, most noticeably) which pays for the show. This is the main reason [[Bleached Underpants|H-games made into anime]] are the most successful financially and on the other extreme, why most '''Anime First''' shows for youngsters are explicitly [[Merchandise-Driven]]. [[Magical Girl]] and Mecha series in particular have a high chance of being '''Anime First'''.


Occasionally manga comes out ''after'' such an anime, but only as a limited run. Some manga run ''concurrently'' to a show, so divergences are common and accepted. You don't want them to be ''exactly'' alike or the audience will wonder why you're [[Overtook the Manga|messing with the story]]. You also rarely get a sort of [[Double Subversion]] where the manga comes out first, but the original project was conceived as an anime; the manga was primarily intended as advertisement. (Two well-known examples are ''[[Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind]]'' and ''[[Neon Genesis Evangelion]]''.)
Occasionally manga comes out ''after'' such an anime, but only as a limited run. Some manga run ''concurrently'' to a show, so divergences are common and accepted. You don't want them to be ''exactly'' alike or the audience will wonder why you're [[Overtook the Manga|messing with the story]]. You also rarely get a sort of [[Double Subversion]] where the manga comes out first, but the original project was conceived as an anime; the manga was primarily intended as advertisement. (Two well-known examples are ''[[Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind (anime)|Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind]]'' and ''[[Neon Genesis Evangelion]]''.)


Not to be confused with the common gripe that all of the anime examples on a trope page come first. (Seriously, guys, it's ''alphabetical''. Either add in some examples from advertising, or let it go.)
Not to be confused with the common gripe that all of the anime examples on a trope page come first. (Seriously, guys, it's ''alphabetical''. Either add in some examples from advertising, or let it go.)


{{examples}}
{{examples}}
* ''[[Neon Genesis Evangelion]]'' is an unusual example of a single show's popularity lasting nearly three decades due to careful merchandising which is still regularly released. Various spinoff manga exist, including the [[Schedule Slip|intermittently produced]] one that ran alongside the ''original'' show (see below).

* ''[[Neon Genesis Evangelion]]'' is an unusual example of a single show's popularity lasting over a decade due to careful merchandising which is still regularly released. Various spinoff manga exist, including the [[Schedule Slip|intermittently produced]] one that ran alongside the ''original'' show (see below).
** Even though the manga began publication before the anime began airing, it was made as a tie-in for the anime which was in production at the time. Amusingly, this manga is ''[[Long Runner|still ongoing 16+ years later]]''...because of [[Schedule Slip]].
** Even though the manga began publication before the anime began airing, it was made as a tie-in for the anime which was in production at the time. Amusingly, this manga is ''[[Long Runner|still ongoing 16+ years later]]''...because of [[Schedule Slip]].
* ''[[Serial Experiments Lain]]''
* ''[[Serial Experiments Lain]]''
* ''[[Soukou no Strain]]''
* ''[[Soukou no Strain]]''
* ''[[Please Teacher]]'' and ''[[Onegai Twins]]'': The manga adaptations differ significantly from the anime plot toward the end.
* ''[[Please Teacher!]]'' and ''[[Please Twins!]]'': The manga adaptations differ significantly from the anime plot toward the end.
* ''[[El-Hazard: The Magnificent World]]''
* ''[[El-Hazard: The Magnificent World]]''
* ''[[El Cazador de la Bruja]]'' : Has a Manga side story to it.
* ''[[El Cazador de la Bruja]]'' : Has a Manga side story to it.
* ''[[Yu-Gi-Oh! GX]]'''s (and now ''[[Yu-Gi-Oh! 5D's]]'''s) manga has the same characters, as well as some new ones, but a totally different plot which bears no resemblance to the original.
* Every ''[[Yu-Gi-Oh!]]'' manga except the original is this; each the same characters, as well as some new ones, but a totally different plot which bears no resemblance to the original.
* ''[[Cowboy Bebop]]''. Two manga series for this show do exist, but they were developed as tie-ins to the anime.
* ''[[Cowboy Bebop]]''. Two manga series for this show do exist, but they were developed as tie-ins to the anime.
** Actually "Shooting Star", which came first, was more of an original [[Alternate Universe]] type story that doesn't really tie in to the anime at all.
** Actually "Shooting Star", which came first, was more of an original [[Alternate Universe]] type story that doesn't really tie in to the anime at all.
* ''[[Samurai Champloo]]''. A two volume manga was published that was a series of mostly original side stories (the only adapted story was a shortened version of the first episode).
* ''[[Samurai Champloo]]''. A two volume manga was published that was a series of mostly original side stories (the only adapted story was a shortened version of the first episode).
* ''[[Tenchi Muyo!|Tenchi Muyo]]''
* ''[[Tenchi Muyo!]]''
* ''[[RahXephon]]''
* ''[[RahXephon]]''
* ''[[Science Ninja Team Gatchaman]]'' and most other shows made by [[Tatsunoko Productions]] (aside from very early stuff like ''[[Speed Racer]]'')
* ''[[Science Ninja Team Gatchaman]]'' and most other shows made by [[Tatsunoko Productions]] (aside from very early stuff like ''[[Speed Racer]]'')
** Even then, the ''Mach GoGoGo'' manga was made primarily to generate interest for the anime. The anime diverted from the manga in many aspects.
** Even then, the ''Mach GoGoGo'' manga was made primarily to generate interest for the anime. The anime diverted from the manga in many aspects.
* ''[[Mai-HiME]]'' was an [[Anime First]], but despite popular belief ''[[Mai-Otome]]'' could better be described as "Anime Simultaneously". The thing was the production teams for the anime and manga were both given the same settings and characters, but worked with them in entirely different ways. So despite what people [[Mis Blamed|think to the contrary]], the manga isn't, nor could it have been, an adaptation.
* ''[[My-HiME]]'' was an '''Anime First''', but despite popular belief ''[[Mai-Otome]]'' could better be described as "Anime Simultaneously". The thing was the production teams for the anime and manga were both given the same settings and characters, but worked with them in entirely different ways. So despite what people [[Misblamed|think to the contrary]], the manga isn't, nor could it have been, an adaptation.
* ''[[Heat Guy J]]''
* ''[[Heat Guy J]]''
* ''[[Ojamajo Doremi]]'', the (now second) longest-running [[Magical Girl]] show in existence, is an example.
* ''[[Ojamajo Doremi]]'', the (now second) longest-running [[Magical Girl]] show in existence, is an example.
Line 38: Line 37:
* Every ''[[Gundam]]'' TV series ever, and ALMOST every OVA series with the exception of ''[[Gundam Unicorn]]''.
* Every ''[[Gundam]]'' TV series ever, and ALMOST every OVA series with the exception of ''[[Gundam Unicorn]]''.
* [[Bee Train]]'s girls with guns trilogy - ''[[Noir (anime)|Noir]]'', ''[[Madlax]]'', and ''[[El Cazador de la Bruja]]''.
* [[Bee Train]]'s girls with guns trilogy - ''[[Noir (anime)|Noir]]'', ''[[Madlax]]'', and ''[[El Cazador de la Bruja]]''.
* ''[[Darker Than Black]]''
* ''[[Darker than Black]]''
* ''[[Texhnolyze]]''
* ''[[Texhnolyze]]''
* ''[[Last Exile]]''.. The sequel series was weird here; The first episode ''technically'' predated the manga, as it was shown at a con. Most viewers were able to see a few chapters of the manga before airing began, though.
* ''[[Last Exile]]''.. The sequel series was weird here; The first episode ''technically'' predated the manga, as it was shown at a con. Most viewers were able to see a few chapters of the manga before airing began, though.
Line 49: Line 48:
** The sequel, ''[[Eureka Seven AO]]'' had the manga come out first - but since the anime was announced at around the same time and was released three months after the manga's first chapter, it's clear the manga is more of an advertisement, in the vein of ''[[Neon Genesis Evangelion]]''.
** The sequel, ''[[Eureka Seven AO]]'' had the manga come out first - but since the anime was announced at around the same time and was released three months after the manga's first chapter, it's clear the manga is more of an advertisement, in the vein of ''[[Neon Genesis Evangelion]]''.
* ''[[The Big O]]''. The order went First Season -> Manga -> Second Season, so the Manga version goes off in a ''completely'' different direction from the show (particularly regarding Beck and the ending). Some ideas from the Manga made it into the Second Season, if somewhat obtusely.
* ''[[The Big O]]''. The order went First Season -> Manga -> Second Season, so the Manga version goes off in a ''completely'' different direction from the show (particularly regarding Beck and the ending). Some ideas from the Manga made it into the Second Season, if somewhat obtusely.
** ...which was followed by Manga (unreleased in the US) based on the Second Season.
** ...which was followed by Manga (unreleased in the US) based on the Second Season.
* ''[[Kujibiki Unbalance]]'' - originally an [[Show Within a Show|entirely fictional]] manga series from ''[[Genshiken]]'', it later spawned a fictional anime - when Genshiken became a real anime, Kujibiki Unbalance got three real episodes, and then became a full-fledged anime series in real life - the manga was released alongside it.
* ''[[Kujibiki Unbalance]]'' - originally an [[Show Within a Show|entirely fictional]] manga series from ''[[Genshiken]]'', it later spawned a fictional anime - when Genshiken became a real anime, Kujibiki Unbalance got three real episodes, and then became a full-fledged anime series in real life - the manga was released alongside it.
* ''[[Infinite Ryvius]]''. The manga is a [[POV Sequel]].
* ''[[Infinite Ryvius]]''. The manga is a [[POV Sequel]].
Line 60: Line 59:
* Anything by gímik. Which is really just ''[[Kiddy Grade]]'' and ''[[Uta Kata]]''. ''[[Gigantic Formula]]'' also counts.
* Anything by gímik. Which is really just ''[[Kiddy Grade]]'' and ''[[Uta Kata]]''. ''[[Gigantic Formula]]'' also counts.
* ''[[Burst Angel]]''. The manga was also a prequal ''to'' the anime.
* ''[[Burst Angel]]''. The manga was also a prequal ''to'' the anime.
* ''[[Hell Girl]]''. The anime and manga began ''releasing'' almost simultaneously, but the former is the original and the latter the adaptation (anime has a longer lead time than manga). The manga's quite different, and lacks Hajime and Tsugumi except in [[Omake|omakes]].
* ''[[Hell Girl]]''. The anime and manga began ''releasing'' almost simultaneously, but the former is the original and the latter the adaptation (anime has a longer lead time than manga). The manga's quite different, and lacks Hajime and Tsugumi except in [[omake]]s.
* ''[[Xam'd: Lost Memories|Xamd Lost Memories]]''.
* ''[[Xam'd: Lost Memories|Xamd Lost Memories]]''.
* ''[[Bubblegum Crisis]]''.
* ''[[Bubblegum Crisis]]''.
* ''[[Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha As]]'' and ''[[Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS|StrikerS]]''. [[Comic Book Adaptation|What manga they had]] were supplementary material for the anime series. The first season isn't an example since it's ([[What Could Have Been|loosely]]) [[The Anime of the Game|based on the]] ''[[Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha]]'' mini-scenario of the ''[[Triangle Heart 3 ~sweet songs forever~]]'' fandisc, [[More Popular Spinoff|though most fans don't know that]].
* ''[[Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha A's]]'' and ''[[Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS|StrikerS]]''. [[Comic Book Adaptation|What manga they had]] were supplementary material for the anime series. The first season isn't an example since it's ([[What Could Have Been|loosely]]) [[The Anime of the Game|based on the]] ''[[Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha]]'' mini-scenario of the ''[[Triangle Heart 3 ~sweet songs forever~]]'' fandisc, [[More Popular Spinoff|though most fans don't know that]].
* ''[[Uchuu Senkan Yamato]]''
* ''[[Uchuu Senkan Yamato]]''
* ''[[Kaleido Star]]''
* ''[[Kaleido Star]]''
* ''[[Super Dimension Fortress Macross]]'', and its sequels (''[[Macross Plus]]'' and ''[[Macross Zero]]'' are the exceptions to subsequent manga adaptations, being [[OVA|OVAs]] and all).
* ''[[Super Dimension Fortress Macross]]'', and its sequels (''[[Macross Plus]]'' and ''[[Macross Zero]]'' are the exceptions to subsequent manga adaptations, being [[OVA]]s and all).
* ''[[Sora wo Kakeru Shoujo]]''. Mecha show? Check. It's even co-sponsored by model and garage kit maker Good Smile Company.
* ''[[Sora wo Kakeru Shoujo]]''. Mecha show? Check. It's even co-sponsored by model and garage kit maker Good Smile Company.
* ''[[Candy Boy]]'' is an odd case. It was originally just an original net animation used to promote a music video. However, the concept for the show proved popular enough that more episodes were created.
* ''[[Candy Boy]]'' is an odd case. It was originally just an original net animation used to promote a music video. However, the concept for the show proved popular enough that more episodes were created.
Line 77: Line 76:
* ''[[Heroman]]''
* ''[[Heroman]]''
* The [[wikipedia:Anime no Chikara|Anime no Chikara]] project aims to create entirely original anime, and so far has resulted in:
* The [[wikipedia:Anime no Chikara|Anime no Chikara]] project aims to create entirely original anime, and so far has resulted in:
** ''[[Sora no Woto]]''
** ''[[So Ra No Wo To]]''
** ''[[Senkou no Night Raid]]''
** ''[[Senkou no Night Raid]]''
** ''[[Seikimatsu Occult Gakuin]]''
** ''[[Seikimatsu Occult Gakuin]]''
* ''[[Kyo Kara Maoh!|Kyo Kara Maoh]]''
* ''[[Kyo Kara Maoh!|Kyo Kara Maoh]]''
* ''[[Star Driver]]''
* ''[[Star Driver]]''
* ''[[Martian Successor Nadesico]],'' which was shortly after adapted into a [[Magitek|much]] [[Alternate Universe|different]] manga.
* ''[[Martian Successor Nadesico]],'' which was shortly after adapted into a [[Magitek|much]] [[Alternate Universe|different]] manga.
Line 102: Line 101:
* ''[[Mawaru Penguindrum]]'', similar to Utena (which was also by Ikuhara), has novels being released simultaneously.
* ''[[Mawaru Penguindrum]]'', similar to Utena (which was also by Ikuhara), has novels being released simultaneously.
* ''[[Digimon Xros Wars]]''. While [[Digimon Xros Wars (manga)|the manga]] debuted first by around a fortnight, the anime was announced and presumably in production for months beforehand and the manga specifically adapts it, so it still qualifies for this trope.
* ''[[Digimon Xros Wars]]''. While [[Digimon Xros Wars (manga)|the manga]] debuted first by around a fortnight, the anime was announced and presumably in production for months beforehand and the manga specifically adapts it, so it still qualifies for this trope.
* Very similar to ''[[Neon Genesis Evangelion|Evangelion]]'', above, ''[[Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind]]'' is a weird example wherein the manga was released first, but primarily to help the production of and promote the (anime) film. This example is further atypical in that the manga wound up being a major [[Adaptation Expansion]], starting its run two years before the film ultimately came out... and finishing ''ten years'' after it, a total run of twelve years. (And unlike with ''Evangelion'', this had nothing to do with [[Schedule Slip]].)
* Very similar to ''[[Neon Genesis Evangelion|Evangelion]]'', above, ''[[Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind (anime)|Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind]]'' is a weird example wherein the [[Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind (manga)|manga]] was released first, but primarily to help the production of and promote the anime film. This example is further atypical in that the manga wound up being a major [[Adaptation Expansion]], starting its run two years before the film ultimately came out... and finishing ''ten years'' after it, a total run of twelve years. (And unlike with ''Evangelion'', this had nothing to do with [[Schedule Slip]].)
* ''[[Saint October]]''
* ''[[Saint October]]''
* ''[[The Boy and the Heron (anime)|The Boy and the Heron]]'' is an original story by [[Hayao Miyazaki]]. It does feature a real world novel, ''How Do You Live?'', whose name served as the tentative English title, but the story of the film is all original. It's further distinguished from other anime in that it doesn't have a production committee, meaning all production funds came out of [[Studio Ghibli]]'s pockets. This allows for a level of creative freedom rarely seen in any ''animated'' production, not just anime.


{{reflist}}
{{reflist}}
[[Category:Trivia Trope]]
[[Category:Trivia Trope]]
[[Category:Japanese Visual Arts Tropes]]
[[Category:Japanese Visual Arts Tropes]]
[[Category:Anime First]]
[[Category:{{PAGENAME}}]]

Latest revision as of 20:10, 16 July 2023

Anime is usually based on manga, light novels, visual novels or video games. Occasionally there are exceptions.

Anime is always more risky than manga. Pretty much everyone has a manga specifically geared to their interest somewhere, and the largely black and white format of manga makes it cheaper to produce than even the average western comic book. Producing a show is much more expensive.[1] And while a lot of manga is made to be accessible and disposable, the demographics of TV watchers is different. This is the major reason anime is mostly populated by shounen and shoujo, as kids simply have more time. Meanwhile, Josei manga rarely ever gets made into anime, if reaching television at all.

Anime also requires voice actors and a hopefully decent animation budget. On the other hand, it's much easier to make a show based on a known money-generating property. Making a show suddenly becomes lucrative once you figure in things like new merchandise (character Image Song and soundtracks, most noticeably) which pays for the show. This is the main reason H-games made into anime are the most successful financially and on the other extreme, why most Anime First shows for youngsters are explicitly Merchandise-Driven. Magical Girl and Mecha series in particular have a high chance of being Anime First.

Occasionally manga comes out after such an anime, but only as a limited run. Some manga run concurrently to a show, so divergences are common and accepted. You don't want them to be exactly alike or the audience will wonder why you're messing with the story. You also rarely get a sort of Double Subversion where the manga comes out first, but the original project was conceived as an anime; the manga was primarily intended as advertisement. (Two well-known examples are Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind and Neon Genesis Evangelion.)

Not to be confused with the common gripe that all of the anime examples on a trope page come first. (Seriously, guys, it's alphabetical. Either add in some examples from advertising, or let it go.)

Examples of Anime First include:
  1. Even a cheaply-done 12 episode anime can literally cost $US 1 Million to produce when all is said and done, and that's the cheap stuff. Mind you, the expensive shows such as Cowboy Bebop cost $US 1 Million per episode. The really high end stuff, like The Tale of the Princess Kaguya, needs around ten million dollars for 20 minutes of animation.