Spiritual Licensee: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
(Import from TV Tropes TVT:Main.SpiritualLicensee 2012-07-01, editor history TVTH:Main.SpiritualLicensee, CC-BY-SA 3.0 Unported license)
 
m (Mass update links)
Line 8: Line 8:
Please do not add personal examples; the main page should be for comparisons that you have seen numerous times (or ones that are really, really obvious).
Please do not add personal examples; the main page should be for comparisons that you have seen numerous times (or ones that are really, really obvious).


Contrast [[Dolled Up Installment]].
Contrast [[Dolled-Up Installment]].
{{examples|Examples:}}
{{examples}}


== Anime & Manga ==
== Anime & Manga ==
Line 88: Line 88:
* ''[[The Cabin in The Woods (Film)|The Cabin in The Woods]]'' makes for a pretty good adaptation of (warning: major spoilers) {{spoiler|the [[SCP Foundation (Wiki)|SCP Foundation]], of all things. The main bad guys are a nebulous organization of questionable morality which possesses an enormous catalogue of monsters and other dangerous supernatural items (in this case, horror movie baddies), which it keeps and controls so as to prevent [[The End of the World As We Know It|an XK-Class end-of-the-world event]]. And when the heroes find out about the lengths they're willing to go to, they take one look and say "fuck it, better to let the world end."}}
* ''[[The Cabin in The Woods (Film)|The Cabin in The Woods]]'' makes for a pretty good adaptation of (warning: major spoilers) {{spoiler|the [[SCP Foundation (Wiki)|SCP Foundation]], of all things. The main bad guys are a nebulous organization of questionable morality which possesses an enormous catalogue of monsters and other dangerous supernatural items (in this case, horror movie baddies), which it keeps and controls so as to prevent [[The End of the World As We Know It|an XK-Class end-of-the-world event]]. And when the heroes find out about the lengths they're willing to go to, they take one look and say "fuck it, better to let the world end."}}
* [[Guillermo Del Toro]] has [http://www.joblo.com/movie-news/guillermo-del-toro-says-at-the-mountains-of-madness-is-dead remarked] that ''[[Prometheus (Film)|Prometheus]]'' is a close enough adaptation of [[HP Lovecraft]]'s ''[[At the Mountains of Madness (Literature)|At the Mountains of Madness]]'' that it's the reason why his own adaptation of ''ATMOM'' [[Development Hell|won't enter]] [[What Could Have Been|production]] -- at this point, it would likely come off looking like a ripoff of ''Prometheus''.
* [[Guillermo Del Toro]] has [http://www.joblo.com/movie-news/guillermo-del-toro-says-at-the-mountains-of-madness-is-dead remarked] that ''[[Prometheus (Film)|Prometheus]]'' is a close enough adaptation of [[HP Lovecraft]]'s ''[[At the Mountains of Madness (Literature)|At the Mountains of Madness]]'' that it's the reason why his own adaptation of ''ATMOM'' [[Development Hell|won't enter]] [[What Could Have Been|production]] -- at this point, it would likely come off looking like a ripoff of ''Prometheus''.
* ''[[The Raid]]'' unintentionally becomes a movie adaption of the ''Dynamite Deka'' series, aka ''Die Hard Arcade'' and ''Dynamite Cop'', by Indonesia (with a Welsh director). The movie has it all: a swat team infiltrating the building, a bad guy barking orders on the top floor, and waves upon waves of mooks on each floor. Even some movie critics said the movie feels like an adaption of arcade [[Beat Em Up|beat'em ups]] from the 90s.
* ''[[The Raid]]'' unintentionally becomes a movie adaption of the ''Dynamite Deka'' series, aka ''Die Hard Arcade'' and ''Dynamite Cop'', by Indonesia (with a Welsh director). The movie has it all: a swat team infiltrating the building, a bad guy barking orders on the top floor, and waves upon waves of mooks on each floor. Even some movie critics said the movie feels like an adaption of arcade [[Beat'Em Up|beat'em ups]] from the 90s.
* Ray Liotta's ''[[Narc (Film)|Narc]]'' has quite a bit in common with ''Max Payne'', moreso than the actual ''Max Payne'' film did.
* Ray Liotta's ''[[Narc (Film)|Narc]]'' has quite a bit in common with ''Max Payne'', moreso than the actual ''Max Payne'' film did.


Line 95: Line 95:
* Simon R. Green's ''[[Deathstalker]]'' series will be immediately familiar and fun territory to any ''[[Warhammer 40000]]'' player.
* Simon R. Green's ''[[Deathstalker]]'' series will be immediately familiar and fun territory to any ''[[Warhammer 40000]]'' player.
* The ''Nina Wilde'' series by Andy McDermott, about a semi-reluctant [[Adventurer Archaeologist]], obviously takes more than a few cues from (and frequently references) Indiana Jones and Lara Croft. However, the number of pitched gun battles in exotic locations and rare vehicles which inevitably explode makes it far more akin to the written form of ''[[Uncharted]]''.
* The ''Nina Wilde'' series by Andy McDermott, about a semi-reluctant [[Adventurer Archaeologist]], obviously takes more than a few cues from (and frequently references) Indiana Jones and Lara Croft. However, the number of pitched gun battles in exotic locations and rare vehicles which inevitably explode makes it far more akin to the written form of ''[[Uncharted]]''.
* ''[[The Hunger Games]]'' is probably the closest that we'll get to an American remake of ''[[Battle Royale]]''. '''[[Fan Dumb|And that is]] [[They Copied It So It Sucks|all that needs]] [[Rule of Cautious Editing Judgment|to be said]].'''
* ''[[The Hunger Games]]'' is probably the closest that we'll get to an American remake of ''[[Battle Royale]]''. '''[[Fan Dumb|And that is]] [[They Copied It, So It Sucks|all that needs]] [[Rule of Cautious Editing Judgment|to be said]].'''
** ...unless, of course, the success of the [[The Hunger Games (Film)|film adaptation]] is enough to convince Hollywood that it's no longer [[Too Soon]] after [[Useful Notes/Columbine|Columbine]] to pull said remake out of [[Development Hell]].
** ...unless, of course, the success of the [[The Hunger Games (Film)|film adaptation]] is enough to convince Hollywood that it's no longer [[Too Soon]] after [[Useful Notes/Columbine|Columbine]] to pull said remake out of [[Development Hell]].


Line 105: Line 105:
** [[Word of God]] says it's suppose to be ''[[The Silmarillion]]'' {{smallcaps|[[In Space]]!}}
** [[Word of God]] says it's suppose to be ''[[The Silmarillion]]'' {{smallcaps|[[In Space]]!}}
* Lucas Buck from [[American Gothic]] and Randall Flagg from [[The Stand]] share so many similarities that American Gothic can almost be considered a tv show starring Randall Flagg and his attempts to have a heir. Like Flagg, Buck is handsome, charismatic southerner who might or might not be the devil or a demon, who is fond of making deals and enslaving others through their vices and desires. He has understated supernatural powers, is seemingly ageless, and most of all wants a son.
* Lucas Buck from [[American Gothic]] and Randall Flagg from [[The Stand]] share so many similarities that American Gothic can almost be considered a tv show starring Randall Flagg and his attempts to have a heir. Like Flagg, Buck is handsome, charismatic southerner who might or might not be the devil or a demon, who is fond of making deals and enslaving others through their vices and desires. He has understated supernatural powers, is seemingly ageless, and most of all wants a son.
* ''[[Parker Lewis Can't Lose]]'' is called "''[[Ferris Buellers Day Off (Film)|Ferris Buellers Day Off]]'''s real adaptation" on this very wiki.
* ''[[Parker Lewis Can't Lose]]'' is called "''[[Ferris Bueller's Day Off (Film)|Ferris Buellers Day Off]]'''s real adaptation" on this very wiki.
* The earliest episodes of ''[[Star Trek the Original Series]]'' owe a ''hell'' of a lot to ''[[Forbidden Planet]]''.
* The earliest episodes of ''[[Star Trek the Original Series]]'' owe a ''hell'' of a lot to ''[[Forbidden Planet]]''.
* ''[[Pushing Daisies]]'' could be called the TV series [[Tim Burton]] never made.
* ''[[Pushing Daisies]]'' could be called the TV series [[Tim Burton]] never made.
Line 111: Line 111:
* ''[[Super Robot Red Baron]]'' (and, by extension, its follow-up successor series ''Super Robot Mach Baron'') can be pretty much considered a live-action version of ''[[Mazinger Z]]''.
* ''[[Super Robot Red Baron]]'' (and, by extension, its follow-up successor series ''Super Robot Mach Baron'') can be pretty much considered a live-action version of ''[[Mazinger Z]]''.
** To the point that, in Spain, footage from ''Mach Baron'' was made into a theatrical movie and retitled "Mazinger Z, el Robot de las estrellas" (''Mazinger Z, The Robot from the Stars'') to benefit from ''Mazinger'' popularity. There was even a comic-book adaptation made by an Spanish artist that lasted some forty issues, and was known to a generation of spanish children as "El Mazinger Rojo" (''Red Mazinger'').
** To the point that, in Spain, footage from ''Mach Baron'' was made into a theatrical movie and retitled "Mazinger Z, el Robot de las estrellas" (''Mazinger Z, The Robot from the Stars'') to benefit from ''Mazinger'' popularity. There was even a comic-book adaptation made by an Spanish artist that lasted some forty issues, and was known to a generation of spanish children as "El Mazinger Rojo" (''Red Mazinger'').
* More than a few have claimed that ''[[Farscape (TV)|Farscape]]'' is what ''[[Blakes Seven (TV)|Blakes Seven]]'' would have been if remade in the 21st Century. They're not far off.
* More than a few have claimed that ''[[Farscape (TV)|Farscape]]'' is what ''[[Blake's Seven (TV)|Blakes Seven]]'' would have been if remade in the 21st Century. They're not far off.
** Paul Darrow (Avon) has explicitly said in a DVD extras interview that he considered ''[[Firefly (TV)|Firefly]]'' to have been the 21st century ''[[Blakes Seven (TV)|Blakes Seven]]''.
** Paul Darrow (Avon) has explicitly said in a DVD extras interview that he considered ''[[Firefly (TV)|Firefly]]'' to have been the 21st century ''[[Blake's Seven (TV)|Blakes Seven]]''.
* ''[[Dark Angel]]'' was [[James Cameron]]'s attempt to make an unofficial live-action version of ''[[Gunnm]]'' (aka ''Battle Angel Alita'') after the official version he was scheduled to direct went into [[Development Hell]].
* ''[[Dark Angel]]'' was [[James Cameron]]'s attempt to make an unofficial live-action version of ''[[Gunnm]]'' (aka ''Battle Angel Alita'') after the official version he was scheduled to direct went into [[Development Hell]].
* ''[[The Borgias]]'' are just close to being an adaptation of ''[[Assassin's Creed II (Video Game)|Assassin's Creed II]]'' that one half-expects [[Assassin's Creed Brotherhood (Video Game)|Ezio and company]] to show up at any time.
* ''[[The Borgias]]'' are just close to being an adaptation of ''[[Assassin's Creed II (Video Game)|Assassin's Creed II]]'' that one half-expects [[Assassin's Creed Brotherhood (Video Game)|Ezio and company]] to show up at any time.
Line 162: Line 162:
*** And in turn, it's been hailed as the sequel ''[[Freedom Fighters (Video Game)|Freedom Fighters]]'' has never gotten.
*** And in turn, it's been hailed as the sequel ''[[Freedom Fighters (Video Game)|Freedom Fighters]]'' has never gotten.
* The ''[[STALKER (Video Game)|STALKER]]'' games are an almost absurdly obvious example of this for classic Russian science fiction novel ''[[Roadside Picnic (Literature)|Roadside Picnic]]'' and its [[Film of the Book]], ''[[Stalker (Film)|Stalker]]''.
* The ''[[STALKER (Video Game)|STALKER]]'' games are an almost absurdly obvious example of this for classic Russian science fiction novel ''[[Roadside Picnic (Literature)|Roadside Picnic]]'' and its [[Film of the Book]], ''[[Stalker (Film)|Stalker]]''.
* Subversion: ''Dynamite Deka'', a 3D [[Beat Em Up|beat-'em-up]] for the arcades and [[Sega Saturn]] released in Japan, was heavily inspired by the ''[[Die Hard (Film)|Die Hard]]'' films to the point that the game's main character, Bruno Delinger, [[No Celebrities Were Harmed|bore more than a passing resemblance]] to [[Bruce Willis]]. When Sega worked on the game's international version, they tacked on the ''Die Hard'' license, renamed Bruno Delinger into John McClane, and modified the main villain into Hans Gruber.
* Subversion: ''Dynamite Deka'', a 3D [[Beat'Em Up|beat-'em-up]] for the arcades and [[Sega Saturn]] released in Japan, was heavily inspired by the ''[[Die Hard (Film)|Die Hard]]'' films to the point that the game's main character, Bruno Delinger, [[No Celebrities Were Harmed|bore more than a passing resemblance]] to [[Bruce Willis (Creator)]]. When Sega worked on the game's international version, they tacked on the ''Die Hard'' license, renamed Bruno Delinger into John McClane, and modified the main villain into Hans Gruber.
** Note that the sequel ''Dynamite Cop'', the international version of ''Dynamite Deka 2'', did not retain the ''Die Hard'' license.
** Note that the sequel ''Dynamite Cop'', the international version of ''Dynamite Deka 2'', did not retain the ''Die Hard'' license.
*** ''Dynamite Cop'' is the best game adaption of ''[[Under Siege]]'' or ''[[Speed (Film)|Speed]] 2'' we will ever see in our lifetime.
*** ''Dynamite Cop'' is the best game adaption of ''[[Under Siege]]'' or ''[[Speed (Film)|Speed]] 2'' we will ever see in our lifetime.
Line 187: Line 187:
** Now the next big RPG from the guy is ''The Last Story'', and merely from the name and logo design (which is all that is known about it) the games looks like another ''[[Final Fantasy]]'' attempt.
** Now the next big RPG from the guy is ''The Last Story'', and merely from the name and logo design (which is all that is known about it) the games looks like another ''[[Final Fantasy]]'' attempt.
* ''[[Red Faction]]'' bears striking resemblance to the Martian society depicted in ''[[Total Recall]]''.
* ''[[Red Faction]]'' bears striking resemblance to the Martian society depicted in ''[[Total Recall]]''.
* ''[[Manhunt]]'' was originally meant to be an adaptation of ''[[The Warriors (Film)|The Warriors]]'', but Rockstar couldn't get the license at the time. They later made an officially licensed ''[[The Warriors (Video Game)|Warriors]]'' [[Beat Em Up]] that is ''incredibly'' close to the film and still averts [[The Problem With Licensed Games]].
* ''[[Manhunt]]'' was originally meant to be an adaptation of ''[[The Warriors (Film)|The Warriors]]'', but Rockstar couldn't get the license at the time. They later made an officially licensed ''[[The Warriors (Video Game)|Warriors]]'' [[Beat'Em Up]] that is ''incredibly'' close to the film and still averts [[The Problem With Licensed Games]].
** Some have suggested that the sequel, ''Manhunt 2'', is a spiritual licensee of ''[[Fight Club]]''.
** Some have suggested that the sequel, ''Manhunt 2'', is a spiritual licensee of ''[[Fight Club]]''.
* While it's pretty unlikely that anyone would ever make a ''[[Perry Mason]]'' video game, the world will always have ''[[Ace Attorney]]''.
* While it's pretty unlikely that anyone would ever make a ''[[Perry Mason]]'' video game, the world will always have ''[[Ace Attorney]]''.
Line 196: Line 196:
* Barring the lack of giant bugs, ''[[Section 8]]'' is the most true adaption of the [[Starship Troopers|Mobile Infantry]] ever.
* Barring the lack of giant bugs, ''[[Section 8]]'' is the most true adaption of the [[Starship Troopers|Mobile Infantry]] ever.
* ''[[Dead Rising]]'' bears so many similarities to ''[[Dawn of the Dead (Film)|Dawn of the Dead]]'' that the game actually carries a disclaimer explicitly stating that it's not based on the movie. At one point, George Romero himself ''autographed'' someone's copy of the game without knowing much about it.
* ''[[Dead Rising]]'' bears so many similarities to ''[[Dawn of the Dead (Film)|Dawn of the Dead]]'' that the game actually carries a disclaimer explicitly stating that it's not based on the movie. At one point, George Romero himself ''autographed'' someone's copy of the game without knowing much about it.
* Aside from being a spiritual entry in the ''[[Luminous Arc]]'' series, ''[[Arc Rise Fantasia]]'' can be seen as a [[Spiritual Licensee]] to the ''[[Tales Series]]''. The characters are in anime-design, there are skits that tend to be on the light-hearted side, costumes can be acquired (though they can only bee seen on the character's portrait) and [[Arson Murder and Jaywalking|it isn't release in Europe]]. Two developers who worked on the ''[[Tales Series]]'' even worked on this game.
* Aside from being a spiritual entry in the ''[[Luminous Arc]]'' series, ''[[Arc Rise Fantasia]]'' can be seen as a [[Spiritual Licensee]] to the ''[[Tales Series]]''. The characters are in anime-design, there are skits that tend to be on the light-hearted side, costumes can be acquired (though they can only bee seen on the character's portrait) and [[Arson, Murder, and Jaywalking|it isn't release in Europe]]. Two developers who worked on the ''[[Tales Series]]'' even worked on this game.
* ''[[Homeworld (Video Game)|Homeworld]]'' was meant to be a ''[[Battlestar Galactica Classic (TV)|Battlestar Galactica Classic]]'' game, but that didn't work out. The resulting game still had the essential story of the original ''BSG'' and the mood of the re-imagined series (despite the game predating the latter).
* ''[[Homeworld (Video Game)|Homeworld]]'' was meant to be a ''[[Battlestar Galactica Classic (TV)|Battlestar Galactica Classic]]'' game, but that didn't work out. The resulting game still had the essential story of the original ''BSG'' and the mood of the re-imagined series (despite the game predating the latter).
* It takes a bit of time to realize that ''[[X-COM]]: UFO Defense'' is [[UFO|not set in 1980, and was not made by Gerry and Sylvia Anderson]].
* It takes a bit of time to realize that ''[[X-COM]]: UFO Defense'' is [[UFO|not set in 1980, and was not made by Gerry and Sylvia Anderson]].
Line 230: Line 230:
* ''[[The Adventures of Bayou Billy]]'' is all but a ''[[Crocodile Dundee]]'' game, having an obvious [[Captain Ersatz]] player character and a plot suspiciously like ''Crocodile Dundee II''.
* ''[[The Adventures of Bayou Billy]]'' is all but a ''[[Crocodile Dundee]]'' game, having an obvious [[Captain Ersatz]] player character and a plot suspiciously like ''Crocodile Dundee II''.
* ''[[Call of Duty Black Ops (Video Game)|Call of Duty Black Ops]]'' is sometimes considered a Spiritual Prequel to ''[[The Rock]]'', spelling out Gen. Hummel's 60's era adventures. It even borrows some of the elements of that movie, namely {{spoiler|a plot to attack the USA with face-melting green gas, a reveal of the truth of the JFK assassination, and American commandos being "disappeared" or forgotten by the government.}}
* ''[[Call of Duty Black Ops (Video Game)|Call of Duty Black Ops]]'' is sometimes considered a Spiritual Prequel to ''[[The Rock]]'', spelling out Gen. Hummel's 60's era adventures. It even borrows some of the elements of that movie, namely {{spoiler|a plot to attack the USA with face-melting green gas, a reveal of the truth of the JFK assassination, and American commandos being "disappeared" or forgotten by the government.}}
* ''[[Iron Storm]]'' is probably the closest you'll ever get to a game adaptation of Orwell's ''[[Nineteen Eighty Four|1984]]'' (general [[Just Before the End]] / [[Ruins of the Modern Age]] grimness, a [[Forever War]] between 20. century megaempires fueled by fanatical propaganda, etc.).
* ''[[Iron Storm]]'' is probably the closest you'll ever get to a game adaptation of Orwell's ''[[Nineteen Eighty-Four|1984]]'' (general [[Just Before the End]] / [[Ruins of the Modern Age]] grimness, a [[Forever War]] between 20. century megaempires fueled by fanatical propaganda, etc.).
* ''[[Phantasy Star]]'' is ''[[Star Wars]]'' made into a console RPG.
* ''[[Phantasy Star]]'' is ''[[Star Wars]]'' made into a console RPG.
* ''[[In Famous (Video Game)|In Famous]]'' has exactly the same premise as ''[[Static Shock]]'', and its hero has precisely the same superpowers.
* ''[[In Famous (Video Game)|In Famous]]'' has exactly the same premise as ''[[Static Shock]]'', and its hero has precisely the same superpowers.
Line 278: Line 278:
[[Category:Audience Reactions]]
[[Category:Audience Reactions]]
[[Category:Spiritual Licensee]]
[[Category:Spiritual Licensee]]
[[Category:Trope]]
[[Category:Trope]][[Category:Pages with comment tags]]

Revision as of 02:23, 9 January 2014

A counterpart of Better By a Different Name in a way, and also a sort of subtrope of Spiritual Successor and Follow the Leader (but not always), in effect a Captain Ersatz of a story rather than a character. It's particularly evident with video games; most people have certain movie characters with tons of potential they dream of playing as in an amazing game, yet as most movie licensed games are terrible, there's almost no chance of that happening...

Technically no chance, anyway. This is when something has nothing to do with a certain series, but evokes almost the same feeling you'd imagine a decent license invoking with a certain franchise, making it (intentionally or not) a Spiritual Licensee.

This can also occur after a developer decides to create a Spiritual Successor to a game from a previously established franchise, but put an original spin on the game to differentiate it from its predecessor(s).

Please do not add personal examples; the main page should be for comparisons that you have seen numerous times (or ones that are really, really obvious).

Contrast Dolled-Up Installment.

Examples of Spiritual Licensee include:


Anime & Manga


Film


Literature


Live Action TV


Stand-Up Comedy


Tabletop Games


Video Games


Western Animation


Other

  • The MagiQuest simulated-adventure franchise, although much lower-tech and modest in scale, is currently the closest that fans of Niven & Barnes Dream Park can come to savoring the fictional mega-theme park's attractions.
  1. Debatably. Basically, they both have Space Marines, a Horde of Alien Locusts and Scary Dogmatic Aliens, but that's also true of several other science fiction franchises.