Spiritual Licensee: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
m (update links)
m (clean up)
Line 47: Line 47:
* Martin & Porter's ''DVD & Video Guide'' calls ''[[A Few Good Men]]'' "the best [[Perry Mason]] movie ever made."
* Martin & Porter's ''DVD & Video Guide'' calls ''[[A Few Good Men]]'' "the best [[Perry Mason]] movie ever made."
* ''[[Snow Day]]'' was originally written as a film adaptation of ''[[The Adventures of Pete and Pete]]'', and it shows.
* ''[[Snow Day]]'' was originally written as a film adaptation of ''[[The Adventures of Pete and Pete]]'', and it shows.
* ''[[Aliens]]'' is often referred to as a stealth adaptation of Robert A. Heinlein's ''[[Starship Troopers]]'' -- and a far superior adaptation to the later officially-licensed film. And even though it was just one suit, ''Aliens'' even had more [[Powered Armor]] than the actual ''[[Starship Troopers (film)|Starship Troopers]]'' film franchise (at least until the third, straight-to-DVD film).
* ''[[Aliens]]'' is often referred to as a stealth adaptation of Robert A. Heinlein's ''[[Starship Troopers]]''—and a far superior adaptation to the later officially-licensed film. And even though it was just one suit, ''Aliens'' even had more [[Powered Armor]] than the actual ''[[Starship Troopers (film)|Starship Troopers]]'' film franchise (at least until the third, straight-to-DVD film).
* The [[Jean Claude Van Damme]] movie ''[[Double Impact]]'' is a better ''[[Double Dragon]]'' movie than the actual ''[[Double Dragon (film)|Double Dragon]]'' movie that miscasts Scott Wolf as one of the Lee Bros. It even had Bolo Yeung (the actor that Abobo was based on in the first place) playing an Abobo-like henchman who throws oil drums at his enemies.
* The [[Jean Claude Van Damme]] movie ''[[Double Impact]]'' is a better ''[[Double Dragon]]'' movie than the actual ''[[Double Dragon (film)|Double Dragon]]'' movie that miscasts Scott Wolf as one of the Lee Bros. It even had Bolo Yeung (the actor that Abobo was based on in the first place) playing an Abobo-like henchman who throws oil drums at his enemies.
* Many ''[[Warhammer 40000]]'' fans like to consider ''[[Event Horizon]]'' canonical.
* Many ''[[Warhammer 40000]]'' fans like to consider ''[[Event Horizon]]'' canonical.
Line 87: Line 87:
* [[The Nostalgia Chick]] said that ''[[WALL-E]]'' is a better adaptation of ''[[The Lorax]]'' than the [[The Lorax (film)|actual film adaptation]].
* [[The Nostalgia Chick]] said that ''[[WALL-E]]'' is a better adaptation of ''[[The Lorax]]'' than the [[The Lorax (film)|actual film adaptation]].
* ''[[The Cabin in the Woods]]'' makes for a pretty good adaptation of (warning: major spoilers) {{spoiler|the [[SCP Foundation]], of all things. The main bad guys are a nebulous organization of questionable morality which possesses an enormous catalogue of monsters and other dangerous supernatural items (in this case, horror movie baddies), which it keeps and controls so as to prevent [[The End of the World as We Know It|an XK-Class end-of-the-world event]]. And when the heroes find out about the lengths they're willing to go to, they take one look and say "fuck it, better to let the world end."}}
* ''[[The Cabin in the Woods]]'' makes for a pretty good adaptation of (warning: major spoilers) {{spoiler|the [[SCP Foundation]], of all things. The main bad guys are a nebulous organization of questionable morality which possesses an enormous catalogue of monsters and other dangerous supernatural items (in this case, horror movie baddies), which it keeps and controls so as to prevent [[The End of the World as We Know It|an XK-Class end-of-the-world event]]. And when the heroes find out about the lengths they're willing to go to, they take one look and say "fuck it, better to let the world end."}}
* [[Guillermo del Toro]] has [http://www.joblo.com/movie-news/guillermo-del-toro-says-at-the-mountains-of-madness-is-dead remarked] that ''[[Prometheus]]'' is a close enough adaptation of [[H.P. Lovecraft]]'s ''[[At the Mountains of Madness]]'' that it's the reason why his own adaptation of ''ATMOM'' [[Development Hell|won't enter]] [[What Could Have Been|production]] -- at this point, it would likely come off looking like a ripoff of ''Prometheus''.
* [[Guillermo del Toro]] has [http://www.joblo.com/movie-news/guillermo-del-toro-says-at-the-mountains-of-madness-is-dead remarked] that ''[[Prometheus]]'' is a close enough adaptation of [[H.P. Lovecraft]]'s ''[[At the Mountains of Madness]]'' that it's the reason why his own adaptation of ''ATMOM'' [[Development Hell|won't enter]] [[What Could Have Been|production]]—at this point, it would likely come off looking like a ripoff of ''Prometheus''.
* ''[[The Raid]]'' unintentionally becomes a movie adaption of the ''Dynamite Deka'' series, aka ''Die Hard Arcade'' and ''Dynamite Cop'', by Indonesia (with a Welsh director). The movie has it all: a swat team infiltrating the building, a bad guy barking orders on the top floor, and waves upon waves of mooks on each floor. Even some movie critics said the movie feels like an adaption of arcade [[Beat'Em Up|beat'em ups]] from the 90s.
* ''[[The Raid]]'' unintentionally becomes a movie adaption of the ''Dynamite Deka'' series, aka ''Die Hard Arcade'' and ''Dynamite Cop'', by Indonesia (with a Welsh director). The movie has it all: a swat team infiltrating the building, a bad guy barking orders on the top floor, and waves upon waves of mooks on each floor. Even some movie critics said the movie feels like an adaption of arcade [[Beat'Em Up|beat'em ups]] from the 90s.
* Ray Liotta's ''[[Narc]]'' has quite a bit in common with ''Max Payne'', moreso than the actual ''Max Payne'' film did.
* Ray Liotta's ''[[Narc]]'' has quite a bit in common with ''Max Payne'', moreso than the actual ''Max Payne'' film did.
Line 124: Line 124:
== Tabletop Games ==
== Tabletop Games ==
* If there was ever a tabletop game version of [[Watership Down]], it would be called [[Bunnies and Burrows]].
* If there was ever a tabletop game version of [[Watership Down]], it would be called [[Bunnies and Burrows]].
* The [[Space Marine|Space Marines]] in ''[[Warhammer 40000]]'' come almost prepackaged from [[Robert A. Heinlein]].
* The [[Space Marine]]s in ''[[Warhammer 40000]]'' come almost prepackaged from [[Robert A. Heinlein]].




Line 141: Line 141:
** Before it underwent major decay, the same was said of ''[[Tomb Raider]]''.
** Before it underwent major decay, the same was said of ''[[Tomb Raider]]''.
** ''Pitfall: The Mayan Adventure'' also seems remarkably influenced by the ''[[Indiana Jones]]'' films.
** ''Pitfall: The Mayan Adventure'' also seems remarkably influenced by the ''[[Indiana Jones]]'' films.
* ''[[Starcraft]]'' reminds many people of, alternatively, ''[[Starship Troopers]]'', ''[[Alien (franchise)|Aliens]]'', ''[[Warhammer 40000]]''<ref>Debatably. Basically, they both have [[Space Marine|Space Marines]], a [[Horde of Alien Locusts]] and [[Scary Dogmatic Aliens]], but that's also true of several other science fiction franchises.</ref> and, as of ''[[Starcraft II]]'', ''[[Firefly]]''.
* ''[[Starcraft]]'' reminds many people of, alternatively, ''[[Starship Troopers]]'', ''[[Alien (franchise)|Aliens]]'', ''[[Warhammer 40000]]''<ref>Debatably. Basically, they both have [[Space Marine]]s, a [[Horde of Alien Locusts]] and [[Scary Dogmatic Aliens]], but that's also true of several other science fiction franchises.</ref> and, as of ''[[Starcraft II]]'', ''[[Firefly]]''.
* Similarly, [[Blizzard Entertainment]]'s other big RTS franchise, ''[[Warcraft]]'', is practically ''[[Warhammer Fantasy Battle]]'' in disguise.
* Similarly, [[Blizzard Entertainment]]'s other big RTS franchise, ''[[Warcraft]]'', is practically ''[[Warhammer Fantasy Battle]]'' in disguise.
* It can also happen between games. ''[[Ōkami|Okami]]'' and ''[[Beyond Good & Evil (video game)|Beyond Good and Evil]]'' have been called "the best ''[[The Legend of Zelda]]'' games of the year" at times.
* It can also happen between games. ''[[Ōkami|Okami]]'' and ''[[Beyond Good & Evil (video game)|Beyond Good and Evil]]'' have been called "the best ''[[The Legend of Zelda]]'' games of the year" at times.
Line 158: Line 158:
** ''[[Freedom Fighters (video game)|Freedom Fighters]]''. One of [[The Spoony Experiment|Spoony's]] favorites, this game has apparently so ''much'' of the movie ''[[Red Dawn]]'' it might be as well THE ''[[Red Dawn]]'' game.
** ''[[Freedom Fighters (video game)|Freedom Fighters]]''. One of [[The Spoony Experiment|Spoony's]] favorites, this game has apparently so ''much'' of the movie ''[[Red Dawn]]'' it might be as well THE ''[[Red Dawn]]'' game.
** ''[[World in Conflict]]'' and ''[[Command & Conquer]]: [[Command & Conquer: Red Alert|Red Alert 2]]'' are "''[[Red Dawn]]'': The [[Real Time Strategy|RTS]]", with the latter even getting the cheesiness down.
** ''[[World in Conflict]]'' and ''[[Command & Conquer]]: [[Command & Conquer: Red Alert|Red Alert 2]]'' are "''[[Red Dawn]]'': The [[Real Time Strategy|RTS]]", with the latter even getting the cheesiness down.
** ''[[Home Front]]'' towers over them all -- its plot is written by ''John Milius himself'' and is basically ''[[Red Dawn]]'' with North Koreans in place of the Russians.
** ''[[Home Front]]'' towers over them all—its plot is written by ''John Milius himself'' and is basically ''[[Red Dawn]]'' with North Koreans in place of the Russians.
*** And in turn, it's been hailed as the sequel ''[[Freedom Fighters (video game)|Freedom Fighters]]'' has never gotten.
*** And in turn, it's been hailed as the sequel ''[[Freedom Fighters (video game)|Freedom Fighters]]'' has never gotten.
* The ''[[S.T.A.L.K.E.R. (series)|STALKER]]'' games are an almost absurdly obvious example of this for classic Russian science fiction novel ''[[Roadside Picnic]]'' and its [[Film of the Book]], ''[[Stalker]]''.
* The ''[[S.T.A.L.K.E.R. (series)|STALKER]]'' games are an almost absurdly obvious example of this for classic Russian science fiction novel ''[[Roadside Picnic]]'' and its [[Film of the Book]], ''[[Stalker]]''.
Line 177: Line 177:
* ''[[Grand Theft Auto Vice City]]'' was already a perfectly good ''[[Scarface]]'' game before ''[[Scarface the World Is Yours]]'' was made. In the leap from screen to game, ''[[Scarface]]'' was basically forced to ''rip off itself''.
* ''[[Grand Theft Auto Vice City]]'' was already a perfectly good ''[[Scarface]]'' game before ''[[Scarface the World Is Yours]]'' was made. In the leap from screen to game, ''[[Scarface]]'' was basically forced to ''rip off itself''.
** Similarly, the Los Santos chapters ''[[Grand Theft Auto]]: [[Grand Theft Auto San Andreas|San Andreas]]'' play out like ''[[Boyz N the Hood]]'' and ''[[Menace II Society]]'', while the Las Venturas section is basically ''[[Casino]]'' (for the main story strand) and ''[[Ocean's Eleven]]'' (for the optional casino heist plot).
** Similarly, the Los Santos chapters ''[[Grand Theft Auto]]: [[Grand Theft Auto San Andreas|San Andreas]]'' play out like ''[[Boyz N the Hood]]'' and ''[[Menace II Society]]'', while the Las Venturas section is basically ''[[Casino]]'' (for the main story strand) and ''[[Ocean's Eleven]]'' (for the optional casino heist plot).
** And to go further back, ''[[Grand Theft Auto III]]'' looks and plays a lot like the ''[[Driver]]'' games that started on the [[PlayStation]]. Essentially, it's ''Driver'' with a criminal [[Villain Protagonist]] and on-foot controls that actually work -- something that it took Reflections, the makes of ''Driver'', four games to get right (something that is [[Lampshade Hanging|lampshaded]] more than once in the ''GTA'' series), by which point it was ''them'' who came off looking like Johnny-come-latelies.
** And to go further back, ''[[Grand Theft Auto III]]'' looks and plays a lot like the ''[[Driver]]'' games that started on the [[PlayStation]]. Essentially, it's ''Driver'' with a criminal [[Villain Protagonist]] and on-foot controls that actually work—something that it took Reflections, the makes of ''Driver'', four games to get right (something that is [[Lampshade Hanging|lampshaded]] more than once in the ''GTA'' series), by which point it was ''them'' who came off looking like Johnny-come-latelies.
** Going in the other direction, some people consider ''[[Saints Row]]'' to be the true successor to ''San Andreas'' and the ''III''-era ''GTA'' games, especially after ''[[Grand Theft Auto IV]]'' went in a more realistic, [[Darker and Edgier]] direction.
** Going in the other direction, some people consider ''[[Saints Row]]'' to be the true successor to ''San Andreas'' and the ''III''-era ''GTA'' games, especially after ''[[Grand Theft Auto IV]]'' went in a more realistic, [[Darker and Edgier]] direction.
*** You could compare the two franchises as college students: where GTA is the serious straight-laced student with a 4.0 GPA, Saints Row is the partying, hard drinking, pot smoking, orgy attending cooler friend.
*** You could compare the two franchises as college students: where GTA is the serious straight-laced student with a 4.0 GPA, Saints Row is the partying, hard drinking, pot smoking, orgy attending cooler friend.
Line 190: Line 190:
* While it's pretty unlikely that anyone would ever make a ''[[Perry Mason]]'' video game, the world will always have ''[[Ace Attorney]]''.
* While it's pretty unlikely that anyone would ever make a ''[[Perry Mason]]'' video game, the world will always have ''[[Ace Attorney]]''.
* Many people have bemoaned the fact that ''[[Act Raiser]]'' never got a real sequel which featured the combination of town-building sim and real-time action (''[[Act Raiser]] II'' was a sequel [[In Name Only]]). But it did. It was called ''[[Dark Cloud]].''
* Many people have bemoaned the fact that ''[[Act Raiser]]'' never got a real sequel which featured the combination of town-building sim and real-time action (''[[Act Raiser]] II'' was a sequel [[In Name Only]]). But it did. It was called ''[[Dark Cloud]].''
* Despite the creator's efforts to give it a more unique art style, ''[[Deadly Premonition]]'' -- while [[So Bad It's Good]] -- remains a closest thing we have that can be considered a ''[[Twin Peaks]]'' game.
* Despite the creator's efforts to give it a more unique art style, ''[[Deadly Premonition]]''—while [[So Bad It's Good]]—remains a closest thing we have that can be considered a ''[[Twin Peaks]]'' game.
** Even moreso than ''[[Alan Wake]]'', which in turn owes a bit for [[Stephen King]]'s work.
** Even moreso than ''[[Alan Wake]]'', which in turn owes a bit for [[Stephen King]]'s work.
* ''[[Eternal Darkness]]: Sanity's Requiem'' is sometimes considered an impressive adaptation of the [[Cthulhu Mythos]]. The game used inspiration from the stories and even the books can be found, but you can't read them, only observe them.
* ''[[Eternal Darkness]]: Sanity's Requiem'' is sometimes considered an impressive adaptation of the [[Cthulhu Mythos]]. The game used inspiration from the stories and even the books can be found, but you can't read them, only observe them.
* Barring the lack of giant bugs, ''[[Section 8 (video game)]]'' is the most true adaption of the [[Starship Troopers|Mobile Infantry]] ever.
* Barring the lack of giant bugs, ''[[Section 8 (video game)]]'' is the most true adaption of the [[Starship Troopers|Mobile Infantry]] ever.
* ''[[Dead Rising]]'' bears so many similarities to ''[[Dawn of the Dead (film)|Dawn of the Dead]]'' that the game actually carries a disclaimer explicitly stating that it's not based on the movie. At one point, George Romero himself ''autographed'' someone's copy of the game without knowing much about it.
* ''[[Dead Rising]]'' bears so many similarities to ''[[Dawn of the Dead (film)|Dawn of the Dead]]'' that the game actually carries a disclaimer explicitly stating that it's not based on the movie. At one point, George Romero himself ''autographed'' someone's copy of the game without knowing much about it.
* Aside from being a spiritual entry in the ''[[Luminous Arc]]'' series, ''[[Arc Rise Fantasia]]'' can be seen as a [[Spiritual Licensee]] to the ''[[Tales (series)]]''. The characters are in anime-design, there are skits that tend to be on the light-hearted side, costumes can be acquired (though they can only bee seen on the character's portrait) and [[Arson, Murder, and Jaywalking|it isn't release in Europe]]. Two developers who worked on the ''[[Tales (series)]]'' even worked on this game.
* Aside from being a spiritual entry in the ''[[Luminous Arc]]'' series, ''[[Arc Rise Fantasia]]'' can be seen as a Spiritual Licensee to the ''[[Tales (series)]]''. The characters are in anime-design, there are skits that tend to be on the light-hearted side, costumes can be acquired (though they can only bee seen on the character's portrait) and [[Arson, Murder, and Jaywalking|it isn't release in Europe]]. Two developers who worked on the ''[[Tales (series)]]'' even worked on this game.
* ''[[Homeworld]]'' was meant to be a ''[[Battlestar Galactica Classic]]'' game, but that didn't work out. The resulting game still had the essential story of the original ''BSG'' and the mood of the re-imagined series (despite the game predating the latter).
* ''[[Homeworld]]'' was meant to be a ''[[Battlestar Galactica Classic]]'' game, but that didn't work out. The resulting game still had the essential story of the original ''BSG'' and the mood of the re-imagined series (despite the game predating the latter).
* It takes a bit of time to realize that ''[[X-COM]]: UFO Defense'' is [[UFO|not set in 1980, and was not made by Gerry and Sylvia Anderson]].
* It takes a bit of time to realize that ''[[X-COM]]: UFO Defense'' is [[UFO|not set in 1980, and was not made by Gerry and Sylvia Anderson]].
Line 221: Line 221:
* Play some classical music, and ''[[Sins of a Solar Empire]]'' could easily pass itself off as a Western adaptation of ''[[Legend of the Galactic Heroes]].'' There's even a mod that lets you import both [[The Empire|the Reich]] and the [[The Republic|Free Planets Alliance]].
* Play some classical music, and ''[[Sins of a Solar Empire]]'' could easily pass itself off as a Western adaptation of ''[[Legend of the Galactic Heroes]].'' There's even a mod that lets you import both [[The Empire|the Reich]] and the [[The Republic|Free Planets Alliance]].
* ''[[BioShock (series)]]'' is a wonderful interactive adaptation of ''[[Atlas Shrugged]]'', only with the [[Author Tract]] [[Deconstruction|deconstructed]] and re-examined.
* ''[[BioShock (series)]]'' is a wonderful interactive adaptation of ''[[Atlas Shrugged]]'', only with the [[Author Tract]] [[Deconstruction|deconstructed]] and re-examined.
** Based on the trailers, upcoming franchise installment ''[[BioShock Infinite]]'' may be (at least partly) a [[Spiritual Licensee]] of [[Thomas Pynchon]]'s ''Against The Day''.
** Based on the trailers, upcoming franchise installment ''[[BioShock Infinite]]'' may be (at least partly) a Spiritual Licensee of [[Thomas Pynchon]]'s ''Against The Day''.
* ''[[Ikari Warriors]]'' was originally planned to be a ''[[Rambo]]'' arcade game. The game's title actually comes from the Japanese version of ''Rambo: First Blood Part II'', which was titled ''Rambo: Ikari no Dasshutsu''.
* ''[[Ikari Warriors]]'' was originally planned to be a ''[[Rambo]]'' arcade game. The game's title actually comes from the Japanese version of ''Rambo: First Blood Part II'', which was titled ''Rambo: Ikari no Dasshutsu''.
* People are calling ''Xenonauts'' a better ''[[X-COM]]'' game than the upcoming one in the making by 2K Games.
* People are calling ''Xenonauts'' a better ''[[X-COM]]'' game than the upcoming one in the making by 2K Games.

Revision as of 03:26, 14 June 2015

A counterpart of Better by a Different Name in a way, and also a sort of subtrope of Spiritual Successor and Follow the Leader (but not always), in effect a Captain Ersatz of a story rather than a character. It's particularly evident with video games; most people have certain movie characters with tons of potential they dream of playing as in an amazing game, yet as most movie licensed games are terrible, there's almost no chance of that happening...

Technically no chance, anyway. This is when something has nothing to do with a certain series, but evokes almost the same feeling you'd imagine a decent license invoking with a certain franchise, making it (intentionally or not) a Spiritual Licensee.

This can also occur after a developer decides to create a Spiritual Successor to a game from a previously established franchise, but put an original spin on the game to differentiate it from its predecessor(s).

Please do not add personal examples; the main page should be for comparisons that you have seen numerous times (or ones that are really, really obvious).

Contrast Dolled-Up Installment.

Examples of Spiritual Licensee include:


Anime & Manga


Film

Literature


Live Action TV


Stand-Up Comedy


Tabletop Games


Video Games


Western Animation


Other

  • The MagiQuest simulated-adventure franchise, although much lower-tech and modest in scale, is currently the closest that fans of Niven & Barnes Dream Park can come to savoring the fictional mega-theme park's attractions.
  1. Debatably. Basically, they both have Space Marines, a Horde of Alien Locusts and Scary Dogmatic Aliens, but that's also true of several other science fiction franchises.