Spiritual Licensee: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
m (update links)
m (update links)
Line 37: Line 37:
** [[George Takei]] called it "a chillingly realistic documentary."
** [[George Takei]] called it "a chillingly realistic documentary."
** The Two Guys from Andromeda have called it the best ''[[Space Quest]]'' movie out there.
** The Two Guys from Andromeda have called it the best ''[[Space Quest]]'' movie out there.
** Interestingly, counting it as an "actual" ''Star Trek'' movie (it would be #10, having come out between ''[[Star Trek: Insurrection|Insurrection]]'' and ''[[Star Trek Nemesis|Nemesis]]'') would "correct" the famous [[Star Trek Movie Curse]], which had been knocked out of whack by ''Nemesis'' being terrible and [[Star Trek (film)|the subsequent reboot]] being pretty decent, [[Broken Base|even if not great]].
** Interestingly, counting it as an "actual" ''Star Trek'' movie (it would be #10, having come out between ''[[Star Trek: Insurrection|Insurrection]]'' and ''[[Star Trek: Nemesis|Nemesis]]'') would "correct" the famous [[Star Trek Movie Curse]], which had been knocked out of whack by ''Nemesis'' being terrible and [[Star Trek (film)|the subsequent reboot]] being pretty decent, [[Broken Base|even if not great]].
* With [[Christian Bale]] starring, ''[[Terminator Salvation]]'' is the closest thing to a Batman vs Terminator film we will ever see.
* With [[Christian Bale]] starring, ''[[Terminator Salvation]]'' is the closest thing to a Batman vs Terminator film we will ever see.
* ''Dark Prince: The True Story of Dracula'' is closer to [[Doctor Doom]]'s origin story than the one in the actual ''Fantastic Four'' film.
* ''Dark Prince: The True Story of Dracula'' is closer to [[Doctor Doom]]'s origin story than the one in the actual ''Fantastic Four'' film.
Line 110: Line 110:
* ''[[Super Robot Red Baron]]'' (and, by extension, its follow-up successor series ''Super Robot Mach Baron'') can be pretty much considered a live-action version of ''[[Mazinger Z]]''.
* ''[[Super Robot Red Baron]]'' (and, by extension, its follow-up successor series ''Super Robot Mach Baron'') can be pretty much considered a live-action version of ''[[Mazinger Z]]''.
** To the point that, in Spain, footage from ''Mach Baron'' was made into a theatrical movie and retitled "Mazinger Z, el Robot de las estrellas" (''Mazinger Z, The Robot from the Stars'') to benefit from ''Mazinger'' popularity. There was even a comic-book adaptation made by an Spanish artist that lasted some forty issues, and was known to a generation of spanish children as "El Mazinger Rojo" (''Red Mazinger'').
** To the point that, in Spain, footage from ''Mach Baron'' was made into a theatrical movie and retitled "Mazinger Z, el Robot de las estrellas" (''Mazinger Z, The Robot from the Stars'') to benefit from ''Mazinger'' popularity. There was even a comic-book adaptation made by an Spanish artist that lasted some forty issues, and was known to a generation of spanish children as "El Mazinger Rojo" (''Red Mazinger'').
* More than a few have claimed that ''[[Farscape]]'' is what ''[[Blake's Seven|Blakes Seven]]'' would have been if remade in the 21st Century. They're not far off.
* More than a few have claimed that ''[[Farscape]]'' is what ''[[Blake's 7|Blakes Seven]]'' would have been if remade in the 21st Century. They're not far off.
** Paul Darrow (Avon) has explicitly said in a DVD extras interview that he considered ''[[Firefly]]'' to have been the 21st century ''[[Blake's Seven|Blakes Seven]]''.
** Paul Darrow (Avon) has explicitly said in a DVD extras interview that he considered ''[[Firefly]]'' to have been the 21st century ''[[Blake's 7|Blakes Seven]]''.
* ''[[Dark Angel]]'' was [[James Cameron]]'s attempt to make an unofficial live-action version of ''[[Gunnm]]'' (aka ''Battle Angel Alita'') after the official version he was scheduled to direct went into [[Development Hell]].
* ''[[Dark Angel]]'' was [[James Cameron]]'s attempt to make an unofficial live-action version of ''[[Gunnm]]'' (aka ''Battle Angel Alita'') after the official version he was scheduled to direct went into [[Development Hell]].
* ''[[The Borgias]]'' are just close to being an adaptation of ''[[Assassin's Creed II]]'' that one half-expects [[Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood|Ezio and company]] to show up at any time.
* ''[[The Borgias]]'' are just close to being an adaptation of ''[[Assassin's Creed II]]'' that one half-expects [[Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood|Ezio and company]] to show up at any time.
Line 129: Line 129:
== Video Games ==
== Video Games ==
* Many people consider ''[[Crysis (series)|Crysis]]'' the best ''[[Predator]]'' game ever.
* Many people consider ''[[Crysis (series)|Crysis]]'' the best ''[[Predator]]'' game ever.
** The ''[[The Hidden]]'' [[Game Mod|mod]] for ''[[Half-Life 2]] '' also feels like a ''Predator'' game.
** The ''[[The Hidden: Source]]'' [[Game Mod|mod]] for ''[[Half-Life 2]] '' also feels like a ''Predator'' game.
* [[Shigeru Miyamoto]] had originally wanted to make a [[Popeye]] arcade game in the early 1980's, but Nintendo's right to the character were revoked midway through production. Miyamoto then took the idea of [[Super Mario Bros.|a scrappy hero]] rescuing [[Save the Princess|a helpless damsel]] from [[Donkey Kong|a hulking brute]] and made video game history.
* [[Shigeru Miyamoto]] had originally wanted to make a [[Popeye]] arcade game in the early 1980's, but Nintendo's right to the character were revoked midway through production. Miyamoto then took the idea of [[Super Mario Bros.|a scrappy hero]] rescuing [[Save the Princess|a helpless damsel]] from [[Donkey Kong|a hulking brute]] and made video game history.
* The [[Kunio Kun]] soccer league games, including Nintendo World Cup may as well be called [[Captain Tsubasa]]: The Game.
* The [[Kunio Kun]] soccer league games, including Nintendo World Cup may as well be called [[Captain Tsubasa]]: The Game.
Line 206: Line 206:
**** ''[[Max Payne 3]]'' is a good video game adaption of ''[[Man on Fire]]''. Just look at the first trailer of the game when Max describes his situation and you will notice the similarities instantaneously.
**** ''[[Max Payne 3]]'' is a good video game adaption of ''[[Man on Fire]]''. Just look at the first trailer of the game when Max describes his situation and you will notice the similarities instantaneously.
* Given the way the grappling hook is used, ''[[Just Cause (video game)|Just Cause]]'' does a better job being a [[Darker and Edgier]] version of ''[[Bionic Commando]]'' than... well... the 2009 ''[[Bionic Commando]]''.
* Given the way the grappling hook is used, ''[[Just Cause (video game)|Just Cause]]'' does a better job being a [[Darker and Edgier]] version of ''[[Bionic Commando]]'' than... well... the 2009 ''[[Bionic Commando]]''.
* ''[[Metal Gear Solid 3 Snake Eater]]'' had, by far, [[Crowning Music of Awesome|the best]] [[James Bond]] [[Crowning Music of Awesome|title song I've heard for a while.]]
* ''[[Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater]]'' had, by far, [[Crowning Music of Awesome|the best]] [[James Bond]] [[Crowning Music of Awesome|title song I've heard for a while.]]
* ''[[Destroy All Humans!]]'' to ''[[Invader Zim]]'', down to having the same tone, humor, and Richard Horvitz voice your [[Exposition Fairy]].
* ''[[Destroy All Humans!]]'' to ''[[Invader Zim]]'', down to having the same tone, humor, and Richard Horvitz voice your [[Exposition Fairy]].
* ''[[Kane and Lynch]]'' has a noted similarity to the films of [[Michael Mann]], specifically ''Heat'' and ''Collateral''. The magazine PC Powerplay specifically noted that the game "[took] some pages out of Mann's notebook."
* ''[[Kane and Lynch]]'' has a noted similarity to the films of [[Michael Mann]], specifically ''Heat'' and ''Collateral''. The magazine PC Powerplay specifically noted that the game "[took] some pages out of Mann's notebook."
Line 220: Line 220:
* ''[[Nie R]],'' as mentioned in its Laconic section, might as well be called ''{{spoiler|[[I Am Legend]]: The Game}}'', especially once [[The Reveal]] is cruelly shown.
* ''[[Nie R]],'' as mentioned in its Laconic section, might as well be called ''{{spoiler|[[I Am Legend]]: The Game}}'', especially once [[The Reveal]] is cruelly shown.
* Play some classical music, and ''[[Sins of a Solar Empire]]'' could easily pass itself off as a Western adaptation of ''[[Legend of the Galactic Heroes]].'' There's even a mod that lets you import both [[The Empire|the Reich]] and the [[The Republic|Free Planets Alliance]].
* Play some classical music, and ''[[Sins of a Solar Empire]]'' could easily pass itself off as a Western adaptation of ''[[Legend of the Galactic Heroes]].'' There's even a mod that lets you import both [[The Empire|the Reich]] and the [[The Republic|Free Planets Alliance]].
* ''[[Bioshock]]'' is a wonderful interactive adaptation of ''[[Atlas Shrugged]]'', only with the [[Author Tract]] [[Deconstruction|deconstructed]] and re-examined.
* ''[[BioShock (series)]]'' is a wonderful interactive adaptation of ''[[Atlas Shrugged]]'', only with the [[Author Tract]] [[Deconstruction|deconstructed]] and re-examined.
** Based on the trailers, upcoming franchise installment ''[[Bio Shock Infinite]]'' may be (at least partly) a [[Spiritual Licensee]] of [[Thomas Pynchon]]'s ''Against The Day''.
** Based on the trailers, upcoming franchise installment ''[[BioShock Infinite]]'' may be (at least partly) a [[Spiritual Licensee]] of [[Thomas Pynchon]]'s ''Against The Day''.
* ''[[Ikari Warriors]]'' was originally planned to be a ''[[Rambo]]'' arcade game. The game's title actually comes from the Japanese version of ''Rambo: First Blood Part II'', which was titled ''Rambo: Ikari no Dasshutsu''.
* ''[[Ikari Warriors]]'' was originally planned to be a ''[[Rambo]]'' arcade game. The game's title actually comes from the Japanese version of ''Rambo: First Blood Part II'', which was titled ''Rambo: Ikari no Dasshutsu''.
* People are calling ''Xenonauts'' a better ''[[X-COM]]'' game than the upcoming one in the making by 2K Games.
* People are calling ''Xenonauts'' a better ''[[X-COM]]'' game than the upcoming one in the making by 2K Games.

Revision as of 00:23, 29 December 2014

A counterpart of Better by a Different Name in a way, and also a sort of subtrope of Spiritual Successor and Follow the Leader (but not always), in effect a Captain Ersatz of a story rather than a character. It's particularly evident with video games; most people have certain movie characters with tons of potential they dream of playing as in an amazing game, yet as most movie licensed games are terrible, there's almost no chance of that happening...

Technically no chance, anyway. This is when something has nothing to do with a certain series, but evokes almost the same feeling you'd imagine a decent license invoking with a certain franchise, making it (intentionally or not) a Spiritual Licensee.

This can also occur after a developer decides to create a Spiritual Successor to a game from a previously established franchise, but put an original spin on the game to differentiate it from its predecessor(s).

Please do not add personal examples; the main page should be for comparisons that you have seen numerous times (or ones that are really, really obvious).

Contrast Dolled-Up Installment.

Examples of Spiritual Licensee include:


Anime & Manga


Film

Literature


Live Action TV


Stand-Up Comedy


Tabletop Games


Video Games


Western Animation


Other

  • The MagiQuest simulated-adventure franchise, although much lower-tech and modest in scale, is currently the closest that fans of Niven & Barnes Dream Park can come to savoring the fictional mega-theme park's attractions.
  1. Debatably. Basically, they both have Space Marines, a Horde of Alien Locusts and Scary Dogmatic Aliens, but that's also true of several other science fiction franchises.