Doctor Who/WMG/Series 5: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
m (update links)
No edit summary
 
(7 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 12:
 
== The Dream Lord is Series 5's [[Big Bad]]. He's trying to bring about the end of the Universe. ==
* There's no freak natural phenomena going on here.'''Someone''', some sentient being, is trying to destroy the Universe. How do we know this? Well, '''someone''' keeps talking. We keep hearing this little nugget in the TARDIS during [[Doctor Who/Recap/S31 /E12 The Pandorica Opens|"The Pandorica Opens"]]:
{{quote|'''Mysterious Voice''': ''Silence will fall...''}}
* The destruction will be caused by the TARDIS exploding. We saw the fragment in [[Doctor Who/Recap/S31 /E09 Cold Blood|"Cold Blood"]], we saw the painting at the beginning of the episode.
* Someone has taken control of the TARDIS and is making it explode--andexplode—and when I say "someone", I mean "'''Someone'''". When the TARDIS starts going apeshit and exploding (thereby causing the destruction/erasure of the entire universe), the Doctor tells River that it must be some kind of fault. River disagrees:
{{quote|'''River''': Someone else is flying it. An external force.}}
* So, who can operate the TARDIS well enough to cause it to explode and destroy the Universe? The Dalek Supreme has something to say on this topic:
Line 23:
** Why? [[For the Evulz|Because he's a dick.]]
*** Specifically, he's a dick because of all the [[The Woobie|pain the Doctor's suffered]], and wants to erase time [[Woobie, Destroyer of Worlds|so he no longer has to be the tragic hero.]]
** How is he able to do all this when he's only a manifestation of the Doctor's dark impulses? [[Fridge Logic|...yeah, okay, good point]] [[TalkingInner to ThemselfDialogue|self]]. Maybe he was able to manifest his own form at some point in the Doctor's relative future. Or perhaps he's inhabiting the TARDIS--telepathicTARDIS—telepathic circuits, remember? This would also fit with the fact that the voice declaring that "silence will fall." is heard ''inside the TARDIS'' (which is supposed to be shielded from most assaults) right before the screen cracks, and at the end of "Amy's Choice" The Doctor saw the Dream Lord's face in the TARDIS console.
*** Or maybe the Doctor was lying.
*** Notes for this theory: River said she was taught to fly the TARDIS by the best in The Time of Angels. Yet she also says "Pity you were busy that day." How to reconcile this statement with the one in the Pandorica? Perhaps the Dream Lord taught her, somehow?
**** She says in [[Doctor Who/Recap/S31 /E12 The Pandorica Opens|"The Pandorica Opens"]] that the Doctor taught her to fly the TARDIS. Later in her personal timeline (i.e. [[Doctor Who/Recap/S31 /E04 The Time of Angels|"The Time of Angels"]]), she says that someone else taught her to fly even better than the Doctor does. She almost certainly met this other TARDIS driver in the intervening time period.
*** In addition, consider the following: Every enemy leading up to this point has been accounted for, except the Dream Lord. The Atraxi, Daleks, and Homo Reptillia are part of the Alliance, and we know they aren't the real [[Big Bad]]. The fish-vampires are still presumably in Venice and their matriarch has been killed. The invisible monster Vincent Van Gogh faced wasn't malevolent, just injured. The TARDIS-like spaceship basically imploded at the end of The Lodger. This means that the real villain behind the destruction of the TARDIS must either be the Dream Lord or someone entirely new to Series 5, which seems unlikely. Barring the return of an old villain like Rassilon or the Master, it seems to follow that it's probably the Dream Lord who is behind this
**** Agreed, but the Dream Lord may be working with other monsters, such as Prisoner Zero and the Starwhale. (He also may have worked with the Krafayis before it perished). Note that although Eleven thinks he knows evil when he sees it, and is convinced that the Dream Lord represents his dark side, none of the threats present in "Vincent and the Doctor" and "The Lodger" are actually malevolent, and the Dream Lord does nothing more than tell him the truth and manipulate his consciousness. Also, as far as Big Bang II is concerned, the Pandorica may serve no function other than that of a Void Ship. Eleven thinks it contains a memory of the universe, when in reality, ''he'' contains a memory of the universe.
Line 105:
 
== The cracks in time and space are being caused by [[The Order of the Stick|the Snarl]] escaping its prison. ==
One part [[Continuity Snarl]] ,<ref>''[[Doctor Who]]'' has been going for almost 50 years: if there was ''ever'' a series in which a [[Continuity Snarl]] would bite the characters in the arse, it's this one.</ref>, one part [[Eldritch Abomination]]. It's been bound in this "Pandorica" place, and it's so massive and powerful that [http://www.giantitp.com/comics/oots0275.html when it starts to escape, cracks appear all across space and time.] The Gate <ref>(Wait, what Gate?)</ref> is Amy, and somehow, her getting married will break open the Pandorica, unleash the Snarl and literally unmake creation.
* Considering that the Doctor actually discussed the continuity issues of the Cyberking in Victorian London, this actually seems quite plausible. Not necisarilly THE Snarl, but something like it.
 
Line 166:
== The cracks in time have been caused by the Doctor driving around time with the brakes on. ==
Well, what happens when YOU drive your car around with the handbrake on? You wear things down.
* So that would make the little joke about this in [[Doctor Who/Recap/S31 /E04 The Time of Angels|The Time of Angels]] [[Chekhov's Gun|important]]...
** Sort-of confirmed.
 
Line 190:
 
== The destruction of the TARDIS was an assassination attempt [[Gone Horribly Wrong]] ==
As of the end of Season 6, we now know that the Silence are not [[Omnicidal Maniac|Omnicidal Maniacs]]s, but [[Well-Intentioned Extremist|Well Intentioned Extremists]] who believe that the Doctor will destroy the universe by asking/answering the First Question ([[Title Drop|Doctor Who?]]), and that killing him will prevent that. ''And'', we know they can send signals into the TARDIS, since they were able to keep Amy's Ganger stable the entire time it was onboard, no matter where in time and space it was. So, perhaps in their attempts to kill the Doctor, they hijack control of the TARDIS and trigger a [[Phelbotinum Meltdown]] to kill the Doctor, or possibly strand him away from the planet where the Question is meant to be asked (though from what we've seen of the Silence, the former seems like the more likely). They just misjudge how strong the explosion is, not realizing it'll result in the very end of the universe they're trying to prevent. And after the universe is rebooted, they learn from their mistake and decide to try a smaller scale assassination, which is what leads to the whole plot with River/Melody.
 
 
Line 291:
* Rory's badge is 20 years out of date.
* Leadworth cannot engender life: the duck pond has no ducks.
* It all adds up to Leadworth being held unnaturally in stasis--outstasis—out of Time, if you will.
* Leadworth seems to be culturally frozen in the year 1996, despite having the technology of 2010. This may be because Leadworth is the closest thing Eleven has to an ideal permanent residence (The neighborhoods of Craig and Vincent are likely second-best). Eleven has a love/hate relationship with all of the places in which he lives, especially the TARDIS herself. His hate for the TARDIS' destinations manifests itself as Time Cracks that suck the life, passion, happiness, and existence out of every place he goes. The technology of these places remains modern, because Eleven has no problem with the strength of his neocortex (other than the fact that his amygdala keeps interfering with its functioning).
 
Line 359:
 
At the end of "Victory of the Daleks", the Daleks escape into the future. This means the surviving Dalek ship can travel through time unhindered, and could return to capture Davros and Dalek Caan before they build the New Dalek Empire, averting the creation of the half-human Doctor clone and the genocide of the Dalek race. They would do this in order to enlist Davros' aid in building the new Dalek race, and to make use of Caan's precognition. The Doctor remembers the invasion for the same reason he remembers the Master's enslavement of the Earth. With the events surrounding the stolen planets never happening in the new timeline, Donna Noble is no longer half-Time Lord but has clearly parted with the Doctor for some other reason at some point between the altered events and present (as she is not present currently). However, as the Doctor is seemingly unaffected by changes in the timeline, he still remembers events as they should have been instead of how they now turned out. Therefore, he still believes Donna would die if she remembered him, and did not realise something was wrong with the timeline until Amy informs him that she does not remember the Dalek invasion.
* Well, since the Cracks erased the Dalek Invasion, as well as the [[Doctor Who/NS/Recap/S4 S30/E14 The Next Doctor|Cyberking incident]], I would consider it '''''confirmed'''''.
 
== The events of ''Blink'' were a giant [[Xanatos Gambit]] on the part of the Angels. ==
Line 371:
== Amy gave The Doctor brain damage ==
There is no way a Scottish redhead hitting you on the head with a cricket bat when you are still in the first 24 hours of your regeneration would not negatively affect the way your brain developed.
* However, since he ''was'' in his first twenty-four-hours of regeneration, [[Doctor Who/Recap/2005 CS the Christmas Invasion/Recap|any damage done to him would have healed]].
 
== The Clerics are a future version of The Church of the Assembly of Man from [[The Return (fanfic)|The Return]]. ==
Line 411:
 
 
== Since the events of ''[[Doctor Who/NS/Recap/S4 S30/E12 The Stolen Earth|The Stolen Earth]]'' and ''[[Doctor Who/NS/Recap/S4 S30/E13 Journeys End|Journey's End]]'' have been seemingly erased, some of ''[[Doctor Who/NS/Recap/S4 S30/E17 E18 The End of Time|The End Of Time]]'' must have been as well. ==
Since Amy cannot remember the Daleks stealing the Earth despite it having been a completely worldwide event that was unescapable, then everyone else (except The Doctor) probably also doesn't remember. Besides the great continuity issues this raises (Donna, The 10th Doctor's clone, Davros, etc...), since Wilfred clearly remembered what happened before during ''The End Of Time'' this means that whatever happened to cause the erasures must have started after that. This means that part or nearly all of that episode may have also been wiped from existence, which probably doesn't mean good things to come for The Doctor, especially if the [[Fan Nickname|Dalek Rangers]] are involved.
 
Line 418:
* This troper thought he was referring to the line "Everything's gonna be fine."
* It was a different Doctor telling her to remember it, though. The one who came back had his jacket on, which he'd very clearly lost moments before. I reckon the Doctor who came back to her, and treated her in a much more kindly, fatherly manner, is a version of the Doctor who had travelled with Amy as a child, the events of which got unwritten from time, and he's still trying to get her to remember them.
** See the [[Viewers Are Geniuses]] entry on the [[Doctor Who/Recap/S31 /E05 Flesh and Stone|Flesh and Stone page]]. The [[It Makes Sense in Context|coat thing]] pretty much confirms this.
* ''Confirmed''. Mostly. See a few entries up.
 
Line 450:
Eleven, along with all his memories, were created by Amy when she wished for someone to fix the crack in her wall. Because she was constantly exposed to the fracture in reality in childhood, the crack in reality absorbed images from her imagination and created the Doctor. No one can remember the events from previous series because they never actually happened.
* This kind of thing could tie in with River Song saying "After all, we're all fairy tales." at the end of Flesh and Stone.
* One can only wonder then what was going through her mind then to create the events of ''[[Doctor Who/Recap/1985 JFIGSA Fix With Sontarans/Recap|A Fix With Sontarans]]''...
* Semi-Confirmed, argubly.
 
Line 476:
* [[Jossed]]. The Doctor was talking to the audience member with the remote/mouse, not any camera man. Who looks directly into a lens to speak to a camera man?
 
== The future Amy and Rory Team TARDIS saw will play an important role in [[Doctor Who/Recap/S31 /E09 Cold Blood|Cold Blood]] ==
Why point them out? Why show Amy and Rory (and subsequently us) them if they aren't important. And yeah, the Doctor may say [[Never the Selves Shall Meet]] but surely he remembers that that actually ''saves the day'' in [[Doctor Who/Recap/S20 E3/E03 Mawdryn Undead|Mawdryn Undead]]. I think that whole scene was to set up a [[Chekhov's Gun]].
* Technically confirmed. Well, it's the absence of the 2020 Rory that's important.
 
Line 499:
** I get my knowledge of Arthurian myth from [[The Other Wiki]] but it claims that the characters were conflated in some sources.
* King Arthur, if he ever existed, came after the Roman occupation had ended, and fought against the Saxon invaders; that's as old as the story can possibly be stretched, certainly not to the Roman times.
* Depending on how much we can take from the original run, it was already established that the Doctor was Merlin -- orMerlin—or an alternate-dimension version of the Doctor was. That storyline was a bit confusing.
 
== Rory is not coming back, and Amy will be killed in the finale. ==
Line 523:
 
Consequently, everything in this season after the first few minutes of the first episode will have been a decoy, the adventures of a Doctor who never should have been, and the show will continue with the other Doctor for the rest of its run. And one day, likely in his twelfth incarnation, he'll see the Dream Lord smiling at him in his reflection, and it'll be time for them to handle that.
** You are correct about Eleven's character development, but you have made the typical mistake of getting the numbers wrong. The Eleventh Doctor signed a five-year contract with the BBC. Although Eleven's next regeneration will bring the Whoniverse into balance, it will not make Eleven happy. Instead, it will give him a more ambiguous personality (as is seen in Jack Harkness and Rory Pond). He will feel incredibly confused. This is when the Master comes into the picture. The Master is an [[Author Avatar]] of Steven Moffat. The Master deliberately created the Eleventh Doctor as a way of de-sterilizing the Whoniverse, and undoing the damage of the Rassilon Era. Rassilon sterilized the Time Lords and prevented Time Lords from reaching their full potential by instilling the Time Lord race with the following genetic programming: Regenerate only twelve times, and do not regenerate unless the need is dire. Do not interfere with the Whoniverse. Merely watch it helplessly while it destroys itself. Rassilon created the first Whoniverse with a SQUICK WARNING: nocturnal emission. He has regretted the creation of the Whoniverse ever since. That's right. Steven Moffat's Whoniverse is the same as Douglas Adams' Universe. The Fourty-second Doctor shall be Arthur Dent. When that happens, the meaning of life shall be 42, because an orgy of 42 people will be required to reboot the universe. In the mean time, the meaning of life is Eleven. The Master intended Eleven to clean up the Whoniverse by dumping all of its Yang force into Pete's World, and then experiencing the pain of both Leadworth, and the London of Pete's World (I suspect these towns are the exact same place). In the Series Seven Climax, Eleven shall re-integrate the Series 5 Whoniverse with Pete's World by screwing the Kings Arms Football Team. (Seven of these people are also Clerics--ElevenClerics—Eleven's companions are stalking him). This is Eleven's biggest crack. When he opens it fully, the orgy will get Amy pregnant with a Time Lord. The Eleven parents of this child are all of the incarnations of the Doctor. When the Master regenerated the Tenth Doctor, all of his incarnations obtained their own bodies, and regenerated into fertile bodies. During the Eleventh Hour of June 26th26, 2010, all of the Doctor's incarnations will merge, and become the Eleven Aspects of Fate. Eleven will be restored to his natural state of incredibly confused. That is when the Master will try to seduce him. He created Eleven because he wanted to repopulate the Time Lord race, and recreate the Doctor according to his own fantasy. (The Master's love for Ten was unrequited). This is a rather sick form of affirmative therapy, but thus far, it as ''somehow worked''. Series Eight will be devoted to the Master's plotline, and Series Nine will be dedicated to Amy's Choice, in which Amy finally gives birth to a Time Lord baby that has been gestating in her womb for five tears. Steven Moffat will then consider Eleven fixed, and offer him a contract renewal, which Eleven shall be free to decline. If Eleven renews the contract, the next season will be a honey-moon for Amy's Choice. She shall marry all of her boyfriends, as well as Sophie and River, but Amy is still heterosexual, so she will be a sister-wife of Sophie and River.
 
== The Dreamlord is not part of the Doctor. ==
Line 565:
 
== The Doctor makes things up to explain what he doesn't have a clue about ==
Back in [[Doctor Who/Recap/S31 /E05 Flesh and Stone|Flesh and Stone]] the Doctor (metaphorically) threw three-year worth of continuity into the Crack when he said that the Angels can choose not to move when they think they're observed. [[Magic A Is Magic A|Which goes against everything we know about them.]]
 
But look at what evidence he'd got. As far as the Doctor knows the Angels have a habit of turning into stones when the only witness around is not looking. Not exactly familiar with the [[Fourth Wall]] and the thousands of tropers behind it, he jumps to the best conclusion at hand. Sensible enough?
 
[[Foreshadowing|Just wait for the next time the stakes rest on his educated guess.]]<ref> and given the way he laments at how others always know much more about [[Arc Words|the Cracks]] than him in [[Doctor Who/Recap/S31 /E09 Cold Blood|Cold Blood]]...</ref>
* Support: In "Amy's Choice," Amy questions The Doctor on whether cold burning suns could actually exists. He's particularly flustered at the time and snaps at her: " I don't know! Why do people always think I know these things!?"
* Who says that Ten was right? As far as we can tell, everything he knows about the Angels in Blink he learned from a [[Stable Time Loop]]. There's no good reason that any non-essential knowledge [[Ontological Paradox|Ontological Paradoxed]]ed into existence need be correct.
 
== The prisoner within the Pandorica is... ==
Line 587:
{{quote|''There was a goblin. Or a trickster, or a warrior. A nameless, terrible thing, soaked in the blood of a billion galaxies. The most feared being in all the cosmos.''}}
** Every ''[[Doctor Who]]'' villain in the known universe would '''absolutely''' show up if they know that someone already had the Doctor locked up in a cage.
** It explains how River could kill the greatest man she'd ever known -- aknown—a hero to millions -- andmillions—and still be ''relatively'' flippant about it: she killed "the Doctor", but not THE Doctor, and got locked up by people who didn't realise the difference.
** This one's confirmed...[[From a Certain Point of View|in a certain sense.]]
* '''...The Black Guardian.'''
Line 701:
 
The Doctor is now locked in the Pandorica. But what's to stop this second Doctor sorting things out? No-one woud have to realise, at least not until the end of the episode where he would have to get them to let him out of the Pandorica (this works best if you assume the duplicate is his future self).
* ''Confirmed'', but the truth is more mundane. It's a set of [[Stable Time Loop|Stable Time Loops]]s in which the Doctor uses the Vortex Manipulator to go back in time, give Rory his screwdriver, and let him out. (Among other things.)
 
 
Line 740:
 
== The TARDIS is evil ==
Remember the psychic pollen? The stuff that draws out your darkest side, created the Dream Lord, all that? Got into the TARDIS's rotors? Oh, yeah, and remember that the TARDIS is ''sentient''? The TARDIS is currently under the influence of its evil side, its equivalent of the Dream Lord. When it started behaving weirdly, taking River Song to the wrong time, locking her in, and then exploding in a cataclysmic universe-destroying explosion--nobodyexplosion—nobody was messing with it. ''It did all that itself.'' [[For the Evulz|For The Evulz.]]
** Holy crap, this is brilliant! It makes so much sense!
** It actually does, I agree. Matt Smith apparently said in one panel that the [[Big Bad]] of the season was in the first episode "but not in a conventional way," the TARDIS has certainly taken some abuse from the Doctor over the years (intentional or not, that could cause some bitterness), and... the TARDIS never died in the 2015 Leadworth dream. It could still be dreaming while its dark side takes over.
Line 757:
* "CLOTHES ON JOHN"? ...so Captain Jack is gonna turn up and '''not''' take his pants off?
** Yes. The new Whoniverse is a Mirror Universe. In the Series 5 Whoniverse, Eleven was biologically programmed to seduce people like Rory Pond or Jack Harkness. In the Series Shag Whoniverse, Jack Harkness is the only person who can refuse to have sex with Eleven, and Eleven is the only person who can refuse to have sex with Rory.
* CHEST JOHN LO NO -- CaptainNO—Captain Jack will appear and have a shirtless scene, but not a pantless scene?
 
** OK. The big name I get out of it is Elton John; that leaves you with COSH, which doesn't make any particularly good words, which is unfortunate. You can also get STONE (which seems to link with the stone Dalek that's been seen) and that leaves you with LOCH JOHN. So god knows what's going on.
Line 766:
** '''Jossed''', and Amy's dad is played by [http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1546076/ ''Halcro'' Johnston], and he has been in some minor parts.
** Eh, it was a reasonable theory. Wikipedia was wrong, so it was based on incorrect information, but I feel my conclusions were reasonable given the available information.
*** You were almost correct actually! You just got the wrong Mr. Pond! The mid-series cliffhanger involves Rory Pond snogging Eleven against the wall of the TARDIS. His reason? He thinks that he and Eleven need to move past their internalized homophobia. Technically, Eleven has already moved past this mentally, but he has not accepted Rory's existence emotionally. The Whoniverse is not fixed. It is a Pete's World with all the sadness dumped into the Series 5 Whoniverse. Even after the "Flesh and Stone" kiss, the Eleventh Doctor felt comfortable in his role. For Eleven, the "Flesh and Stone" snog was a localized Time Loop and out-of-body experience, so Eleven had as much time as he wanted to examine the situation. He determined that there was a 50% chance of Amy's plotline having a happy ending, and decided that 50% was acceptable odds. Eleven may have been a lot more scared of the snog with Rory (which I like to call the "Stone and Flesh" cliffhanger). This would explain why it was uncertain for a few weeks in October of 2010 whether or not the Eleventh Doctor would reprise his role in Series Seven. Note that Eleven was a lot more committed to portraying the second half of Series 5. Luckily he's decided to portray Series Seven despite the fact that it climaxes with his worst nightmare.
*** Mid-series cliffhanger nonsense Jossed.
*** As of "The Wedding of River Song" we've got ''another'' Mr. Pond, who has far more potential for villainy than the other two...
Line 910:
 
== The chickeny monster thing from "Vincent and the Doctor" is a [[Shout-Out]] ==
Specifically, to [[Discworld]]. I mean seriously, a brilliant [[Mad Artist]] is the only one who can see an invisible chicken monster that's slow driving him mad(der)? That's straight out of ''[[Discworld/Thud|Thud!]]!''
* ...damn, that actually makes sense!
 
== Three of the Five Arc Phrases from Series Five are: ==
"The Beast Below"
 
Line 1,045:
** Probably not, given that Moffat seems to like Rose a lot, some "clingy" jokes aside.
* The "Cracks in Time" [[Myth Arc]] has the rather convenient side effect of completely erasing the fannish silliness that was ''The Stolen Earth/Journey's End'' and the historically incompatible ending to ''The Next Doctor''.
* Not only are the old-style Daleks killed off -- violently -- theoff—violently—the new ones promptly ''run away'' and are only seen sparingly afterward, in contrast to Davies' overuse of them.
** That's...not what happened. At best, that's a white lie. "Running away" sounds like a loss.
* Shipping is punted out the window and then shot at, with lasers. The Doctor reacts with abject horror to Amy's come-ons (which, on her part, are pretty poorly thought out), doesn't appreciate Amy's fangirlish insistence that he and River will eventually get married, and generally takes any chance he can get to tactfully imply that this incarnation doesn't find [[Interspecies Romance]] appealing in the slightest. [[Married to the Job|He does enjoy flirting with]] [[Cargo Ship|The TARDIS]], though.
Line 1,056:
 
== The good man that River kills. ==
Isn't {{spoiler|the Doctor. It's Rory. Firstly because the Doctor is plainly going to survive. And secondly because it's just so obvious that it can't possibly be the Doctor. It's like reverse psychology or whatever. Make it seem like she's talking about the Doctor when it's actually not.}} Fair warning, I haven't seen "A Good Man Goes To War" yet because I live in the US, so Idunno if this is late to the game but...yeah.
 
Isn't {{spoiler|the Doctor. It's Rory. Firstly because the Doctor is plainly going to survive. And secondly because it's just so obvious that it can't possibly be the Doctor. It's like reverse psychology or whatever. Make it seem like she's talking about the Doctor when it's actually not.}} Fair warning, I haven't seen "A Good Man Goes To War" yet because I live in the US, so Idunno if this is late to the game but...yeah.
* Jossed. Technically, no-one is killed, but what she's accused of murdering is the Doctor.
 
{{reflist}}
__NOTOC__
[[Category:Doctor Who Series 5{{TOPLEVELPAGE}}]]
[[Category:WMG]]
[[Category:Wild Mass Guessing/Live Action TV]]
__NOTOC__
[[Category:Doctor Who]]