Doctor Who/Headscratchers/Series 1: Difference between revisions

m
no edit summary
m (update links)
mNo edit summary
 
(One intermediate revision by one other user not shown)
Line 1:
{{work}}
 
<!-- %%% -->
<!-- %%Rose -->
<!-- %%% -->
== The End of the World ==
* Jabe holds down the lever to make the giant fans go slower. First, is there no way to just turn the fans ''off''? Second, she actually sacrifices her life to keep pulling this lever, but then after she dies the Doctor manages to get through the last fan anyway (albeit with difficulty). So was her sacrifice in vain? Third, wouldn't it make more sense for the Doctor to get around the fans by hanging off the side of the walkway and shuffling over? The fans weren't so close that they'd cut his fingers. And this way, he wouldn't need any lever-pulling to begin with.
** For the first point, the fans are clearly controlling the cooling -- andcooling—and presumably the air flow -- forflow—for the station; switch them off, and given the immense amount of heat that is building outside and is already getting in thanks to the 'no-shields' situation, the temperature will rise to incredibly dangerous levels incredibly quickly, the air will stop circulating, and everyone inside will either literally boil to death or suffocate, which isn't exactly an ideal situation. Presumably slowing them is a bit better than stopping them outright. Secondly, the question's already kind of answered by the fact that it's clearly difficult enough for the Doctor to do the 'fan-stepping' thing ''once'' with any great swiftness; since he clearly has to stop, focus and time his step exactly to cross every fan, and he's also on a rapidly diminishing timer, he doesn't really have time to do it for each fan -- hefan—he only does it the once because he's out of options and because Jabe's sacrifice bought him enough time to get past the first two fans. As for the third, that's essentially asking him to inch across a very narrow platform over what is obviously a very large drop by his fingertips; not easy, not quick, and if he slips up once he falls to a very messy death and everyone dies.
* Why does the Doctor execute Cassandra? (Yeah, technically he just "allows" her to die, but he set it up that way. She would've lived if he hadn't reverse-teleported her and then refused her life-sustaining moisturization. Also yes, I know that {{spoiler|Cassandra doesn't actually die here}}, but the Doctor didn't know that.) I mean yeah, I get it, she was a murderer. But fast-forward to {{spoiler|The Sound of Drums and you find that the Master is far far worse. Cassandra claims that she'd weasel her way out of a trial, but why can't the Doctor just lock her up personally? (That's what he planned to do to the Master, actually). The Doctor's only other justification is that "everything has to die sometime", i.e. Cassandra is over two thousand years old and she's lived long enough. But of course the Master is a Time Lord and he's plenty old himself. So why save the Master and not Cassandra?}}
** The Ninth Doctor dealt with Cassandra, and the Tenth dealt with the master. Different Doctors, different standards of justice.
Line 129 ⟶ 127:
[[Category:Live Action TV/Headscratchers]]
[[Category:Headscratchers]]
__NOTOC__[[Category:Pages with comment tags]]
[[Category:Doctor Who]]