Come for the X, Stay for the Y: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
No edit summary
("comics"->"comic books"; moved Mad and Cracked.com out of Comic Books and into Periodicals and Web Original, respectively; updated work link)
Line 112: Line 112:
** ''[[Yu-Gi-Oh (anime)|Yu-Gi-Oh]]:'' Come for the card games, stay for the card games.
** ''[[Yu-Gi-Oh (anime)|Yu-Gi-Oh]]:'' Come for the card games, stay for the card games.


== Comic Books ==

== Comics ==
* ''[[Empowered]]'': Come for the [[Fan Service]] and comedy, stay for the intricately-weaved plot and well-written characters.
* ''[[Empowered]]'': Come for the [[Fan Service]] and comedy, stay for the intricately-weaved plot and well-written characters.
* ''[[Scott Pilgrim]]'': Come for the simple premise and video game references, stay for the surprisingly deep story that comes from it.
* ''[[Scott Pilgrim]]'': Come for the simple premise and video game references, stay for the surprisingly deep story that comes from it.
Line 121: Line 120:
* ''[[The Sandman]]'': Come for the horror stories, stay for one of the best comic books that can be compared to a fantasy novel.
* ''[[The Sandman]]'': Come for the horror stories, stay for one of the best comic books that can be compared to a fantasy novel.
* ''[[Cable and Deadpool]]'': Come for [[Deadpool]], stay for the complex plots, [[Cable and Deadpool/Ho Yay|Ho Yay]], and interesting character developments.
* ''[[Cable and Deadpool]]'': Come for [[Deadpool]], stay for the complex plots, [[Cable and Deadpool/Ho Yay|Ho Yay]], and interesting character developments.
* [[Mad]]: Come for the TV and Movie parodies, stay for [[Spy vs. Spy]], [[Ask a Stupid Question|Snappy Answers To Stupid Questions]], and so forth.
* [[Cracked.com]]: Come for the gut-busting "top five" lists, stay for the even more gut-busting fan poster contests.



== Fan Works ==
== Fan Works ==
* ''[[Neon Genesis Evangelion|A Glass of Wine]]'': Come for the sex, stay for the heartwarming.
* ''[[Neon Genesis Evangelion|A Glass of Wine]]'': Come for the sex, stay for the heartwarming.
* ''[[Necaberints Phalanx|Phalanx]]'': Come for the unique concept, stay for the [[Character Development]].
* ''[[Phalanx (fanfic)|Phalanx]]'' by necaberint: Come for the unique concept, stay for the [[Character Development]].
* ''[[Ah! My Goddess|Scordatura]]'': Come for the [[Love Triangle]], stay for the humor and well, the [[Love Triangle]].
* ''[[Ah! My Goddess|Scordatura]]'': Come for the [[Love Triangle]], stay for the humor and well, the [[Love Triangle]].
* ''[[Gears of War|Snowblind]]'': Come for the concept, stay for the epicness.
* ''[[Gears of War|Snowblind]]'': Come for the concept, stay for the epicness.
Line 137: Line 133:
* ''Batman Versus Barney'': Come for the novelty - and sheer perversity - of seeing [[Barney and Friends|Barney the Dinosaur]] in the ''[[Batman: The Animated Series]]'' continuity, stay because it's a surprisingly well-written and dark tale with violence and horror you'll scarcely see on the actual show, plus a thoroughly bloodthirsty and oddly [[Foe Yay]] [[The Joker|Joker]].
* ''Batman Versus Barney'': Come for the novelty - and sheer perversity - of seeing [[Barney and Friends|Barney the Dinosaur]] in the ''[[Batman: The Animated Series]]'' continuity, stay because it's a surprisingly well-written and dark tale with violence and horror you'll scarcely see on the actual show, plus a thoroughly bloodthirsty and oddly [[Foe Yay]] [[The Joker|Joker]].
* ''[[Undocumented Features]]'': Come for the storyline involving your favorite show/film/book. Stay for the freakin' Awesome it inevitably crosses over into.
* ''[[Undocumented Features]]'': Come for the storyline involving your favorite show/film/book. Stay for the freakin' Awesome it inevitably crosses over into.



== Films -- Animation ==
== Films -- Animation ==
Line 150: Line 145:
* ''[[Fantasia]]'': Come for the dancing hippos and [[Mickey Mouse]] dressed as a wizard, stay for [[Fantasia/Nightmare Fuel|Chernabog]].
* ''[[Fantasia]]'': Come for the dancing hippos and [[Mickey Mouse]] dressed as a wizard, stay for [[Fantasia/Nightmare Fuel|Chernabog]].
* ''[[Despicable Me]]'': Come for the funny moments, a [[Harmless Villain]] and his adorable minions trying to conquer the world, stay for {{spoiler|[[Crowning Moment of Heartwarming|the story that leads to Gru's puppet book]]}}.
* ''[[Despicable Me]]'': Come for the funny moments, a [[Harmless Villain]] and his adorable minions trying to conquer the world, stay for {{spoiler|[[Crowning Moment of Heartwarming|the story that leads to Gru's puppet book]]}}.



== Films -- Live-Action ==
== Films -- Live-Action ==
Line 181: Line 175:
* ''[[Real Steel]]'': Come for the giant robots fights (both in size of the fights and the fighters) stay for the story of Father and Son bonding.
* ''[[Real Steel]]'': Come for the giant robots fights (both in size of the fights and the fighters) stay for the story of Father and Son bonding.
* ''[[Starship Troopers (film)|Starship Troopers]]'': Come to watch [[Bug War|guys shoot giant bugs]], stay for the hammy propaganda. "[[Memetic Mutation|Would you like to know more?]]"
* ''[[Starship Troopers (film)|Starship Troopers]]'': Come to watch [[Bug War|guys shoot giant bugs]], stay for the hammy propaganda. "[[Memetic Mutation|Would you like to know more?]]"



== Literature ==
== Literature ==
Line 288: Line 281:
* ''[[How I Met Your Mother]]'': come for Barney Stinson's antics, stay for the [[Continuity Porn]].
* ''[[How I Met Your Mother]]'': come for Barney Stinson's antics, stay for the [[Continuity Porn]].
* ''[[House (TV series)|House]]'': Come for [[Hugh Laurie]], stay for the enthralling character subplots. The medicine's okay, I guess…
* ''[[House (TV series)|House]]'': Come for [[Hugh Laurie]], stay for the enthralling character subplots. The medicine's okay, I guess…



== Music ==
== Music ==
Line 307: Line 299:
* [[Elton John]]: Come for the [[Making a Spectacle of Yourself|goofy glasses]] and [[Costume Porn|wacky costumes]] (at least until [[The Nineties]]), stay for the [[Crowning Music of Awesome|catchy, diverse and well-written music]].
* [[Elton John]]: Come for the [[Making a Spectacle of Yourself|goofy glasses]] and [[Costume Porn|wacky costumes]] (at least until [[The Nineties]]), stay for the [[Crowning Music of Awesome|catchy, diverse and well-written music]].


== Periodicals ==
* ''[[Mad]]'': Come for the TV and Movie parodies, stay for [[Spy vs. Spy]], [[Ask a Stupid Question|Snappy Answers To Stupid Questions]], and so forth.


== Pro Wrestling ==
== Pro Wrestling ==
Line 312: Line 306:
* [[WCW]]: Come for the [[New World Order|nWo]], stay for the cruiserweights.
* [[WCW]]: Come for the [[New World Order|nWo]], stay for the cruiserweights.
* [[TNA]]: Come for [[Kurt Angle]] and [[Wrestler/Sting|Sting]], stay for the X-Division.
* [[TNA]]: Come for [[Kurt Angle]] and [[Wrestler/Sting|Sting]], stay for the X-Division.



== Sports ==
== Sports ==
* [[Super Bowl]]: Come for the football, stay for the commercials (sometimes the main reason people are watching the Superbowl, except maybe hopes for another [[Wardrobe Malfunction]]).
* [[Super Bowl]]: Come for the football, stay for the commercials (sometimes the main reason people are watching the Superbowl, except maybe hopes for another [[Wardrobe Malfunction]]).



== Tabletop Games ==
== Tabletop Games ==
Line 324: Line 316:
*** For the [[Game Master|Dungeon Master]] in you, come for the excuse to build your impassable dungeon to crush your friends, stay for the moments when you let the same friends win anyway, because their solution was just that [[Crowning Moment of Awesome|COOL!]]
*** For the [[Game Master|Dungeon Master]] in you, come for the excuse to build your impassable dungeon to crush your friends, stay for the moments when you let the same friends win anyway, because their solution was just that [[Crowning Moment of Awesome|COOL!]]
* ''[[Exalted]]'': Come because your D&D friend said it was worth a shot, stay for the ability to punch gods' faces in.
* ''[[Exalted]]'': Come because your D&D friend said it was worth a shot, stay for the ability to punch gods' faces in.



== Theater ==
== Theater ==
Line 331: Line 322:
* ''[[Walking with Dinosaurs]]: The Arena Spectacular'': Come for the life-sized dinosaurs, stay for the [[Crowning Moment of Heartwarming]] between the mother T-rex and her baby.
* ''[[Walking with Dinosaurs]]: The Arena Spectacular'': Come for the life-sized dinosaurs, stay for the [[Crowning Moment of Heartwarming]] between the mother T-rex and her baby.
* ''[[Les Misérables (theatre)|Les Misérables]]'': Come for the ginormous barricade and/or well-known songs, stay for the epic story.
* ''[[Les Misérables (theatre)|Les Misérables]]'': Come for the ginormous barricade and/or well-known songs, stay for the epic story.



== Video Games ==
== Video Games ==
* ''[[Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective|Ghost Trick]]'': Come because it's the [[Spiritual Successor]] of ''[[Ace Attorney]]'', stay for the plot twists, smooth animation, plot twists, deep mysteries, plot twists, and [[Department of Redundancy Department|plot twists]].
* ''[[Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective]]'': Come because it's the [[Spiritual Successor]] of ''[[Ace Attorney]]'', stay for the plot twists, smooth animation, plot twists, deep mysteries, plot twists, and [[Department of Redundancy Department|plot twists]].
* ''[[Gears of War]]'': Come for [[Impossibly Cool Weapon|the rifle with a chainsaw for a bayonette]], stay for the tactical combat.
* ''[[Gears of War]]'': Come for [[Impossibly Cool Weapon|the rifle with a chainsaw for a bayonette]], stay for the tactical combat.
* ''[[Halo (series)|Halo]]'': Come for the tactical combat, stay for the plot and [[Halo (series)/Awesome Music|the soundtrack.]]
* ''[[Halo (series)|Halo]]'': Come for the tactical combat, stay for the plot and [[Halo (series)/Awesome Music|the soundtrack.]]
Line 411: Line 401:
* ''[[Warcraft]]'' III come for the awesome gameplay and storyline, stay for [[Defense of the Ancients|DOTA]].
* ''[[Warcraft]]'' III come for the awesome gameplay and storyline, stay for [[Defense of the Ancients|DOTA]].
* ''[[Civilization]]'' come to win the games in different endings, stay for the leaders.
* ''[[Civilization]]'' come to win the games in different endings, stay for the leaders.



== Visual Novels ==
== Visual Novels ==
Line 423: Line 412:
* ''[[Kana: Little Sister]]'': Come for one kind of [[A Date with Rosie Palms|jerker]], stay for the [[Tear Jerker|other]].
* ''[[Kana: Little Sister]]'': Come for one kind of [[A Date with Rosie Palms|jerker]], stay for the [[Tear Jerker|other]].
* ''[[Fate/stay night]]'': Come for the swords, stay for the [[Character Development]] and [[Determinator|unbreakable]] main characters.
* ''[[Fate/stay night]]'': Come for the swords, stay for the [[Character Development]] and [[Determinator|unbreakable]] main characters.



== Web Comics ==
== Web Comics ==
Line 452: Line 440:
** ''[[Irregular Webcomic]]'': Come for the insanely overpowered fireballs, stay for [[The Rant|the often insightful comments and literal rants]]. Doubly so now that the comic itself is essentially finished but the rants keep getting updates.
** ''[[Irregular Webcomic]]'': Come for the insanely overpowered fireballs, stay for [[The Rant|the often insightful comments and literal rants]]. Doubly so now that the comic itself is essentially finished but the rants keep getting updates.
* ''[[Shiniez]]'': Come for the well-drawn fetish artwork, stay for the characterisation, story-telling and sense of humor.
* ''[[Shiniez]]'': Come for the well-drawn fetish artwork, stay for the characterisation, story-telling and sense of humor.



== Web Original ==
== Web Original ==
Line 497: Line 484:
* ''[[Marble Hornets]]'': come for [[Slender Man]], stay because [[Nightmare Fuel|you're too afraid to move]].
* ''[[Marble Hornets]]'': come for [[Slender Man]], stay because [[Nightmare Fuel|you're too afraid to move]].
* [https://web.archive.org/web/20111008114125/http://www.patheos.com/community/slacktivist The Slacktivist's blog]: Come for ''[[Left Behind]]'' getting [[MST|ripped a new one]], stay for the political and philosophical posts. And ''[[Left Behind]]'' [[Snark Bait|getting ripped a new one]].
* [https://web.archive.org/web/20111008114125/http://www.patheos.com/community/slacktivist The Slacktivist's blog]: Come for ''[[Left Behind]]'' getting [[MST|ripped a new one]], stay for the political and philosophical posts. And ''[[Left Behind]]'' [[Snark Bait|getting ripped a new one]].
* [[Cracked.com]]: Come for the gut-busting "top five" lists, stay for the even more gut-busting fan poster contests.



== Western Animation ==
== Western Animation ==
Line 528: Line 515:
** Come for the [[Watch It for the Meme|Memes]], stay for the good animation, characters, and writing.
** Come for the [[Watch It for the Meme|Memes]], stay for the good animation, characters, and writing.
* ''[[Garfield and Friends]]'': Come because you read Garfield as a kid, stay for the hilarious jokes and fourth wall breaking.
* ''[[Garfield and Friends]]'': Come because you read Garfield as a kid, stay for the hilarious jokes and fourth wall breaking.



== [[Real Life]] ==
== [[Real Life]] ==

Revision as of 21:00, 31 August 2020

You're browsing around, and you find out about something that looks neat. A new TV show, a new movie, a new book, maybe a video game. You don't know anything about it, but it looks neat. Something about it jumps out at you. Could be the humor, could be the action, could be the eye-candy. So you decide to try it out.

And it turns out the show is pretty good, too, and you like it. But over time, you start to like it for a completely different reason. This show with the cute lead character actually has an interesting side character with an in-depth story that you're really getting into. Or this movie might be very funny, but it also has some great undercurrents of drama that you weren't expecting, and that really jump out at you. Either way, you end up really liking the show/movie/book/game/etc for a reason completely different from why you started to check it out.

This is an example of Come for the X, Stay for the Y. You originally start to get into something for reason X, but in the end, it's reason Y that causes you to get hooked and stick around.

See also Sex Sells, which is the sub-trope of this. Watch It for the Meme may lead to this. Compare I Read It for the Articles and contrast Just Here for Godzilla.

Examples of Come for the X, Stay for the Y include:

Anime and Manga

Comic Books

Fan Works

Films -- Animation

Films -- Live-Action

Literature

Live-Action TV

Xander: Sunnydale: Come for the food, stay for the dismemberment.
Nancy: There's food?

Music

Periodicals

Pro Wrestling

  • ECW: Come for the bloodshed and Garbage Wrestling, stay for the incredibly well-done matches, surprisingly deep characterization, brilliant promos, and awesome commentary from Joey Styles. This is as opposed to the current WWE-backed ECW Revival, where you come for the name, and stay for Matt Striker's awesome commentary.
  • WCW: Come for the nWo, stay for the cruiserweights.
  • TNA: Come for Kurt Angle and Sting, stay for the X-Division.

Sports

  • Super Bowl: Come for the football, stay for the commercials (sometimes the main reason people are watching the Superbowl, except maybe hopes for another Wardrobe Malfunction).

Tabletop Games

  • Magic: The Gathering: Come to build an army of all different kinds of monsters and spells, stay for the surprisingly in-depth and realistic color/alignment system.
  • Dungeons & Dragons: Come to see what the fuss is about, stay for the adventures you will have and the stories you will share.
    • Or, come for the funny-shaped dice, stay for the funny faces your DM will make when he hears your character's latest in-game plan.
      • For the Dungeon Master in you, come for the excuse to build your impassable dungeon to crush your friends, stay for the moments when you let the same friends win anyway, because their solution was just that COOL!
  • Exalted: Come because your D&D friend said it was worth a shot, stay for the ability to punch gods' faces in.

Theater

Video Games

Visual Novels

Web Comics

Web Original

What's-Her-Face: Cheerleader! Are you here to see Brainkrieg?
Cheerleader: I come for the wuggas, but stay for the jiggy juggas.
Death metal band on the stage: (offscreen) Jugga jigga wugga!

  • Valenth: Come for the pretty adoptable artwork, stay for the surprisingly complex storyline. (Or rather, you could, before the site shut down.)
  • Personality Cafe: Come for the personality typing, stay for the community.
    • Or come because Typology Central banned you, stay for the community.
  • Fanfiction.net: Come because you like the work, stay for awesome expansion upon Canon.
    • Or you come for more of your favorite works and stay to find truly great fics hidden underneath piles of Sues and Yaoi.
    • Alternatively, come to make crappy fanfics, stay to gradually improve and make something fairly interesting! (It takes some time though!)
  • Dragon Ball Abridged: Come to watch Nappa slowly drive Vegata insane, stay to watch Ghost Nappa slowly drive Vegeta insane.
  • Neopets: Come for the cute creatures, stay for the games.
    • Or alternatively, come for the games, stay for the plots and possibly the community.
  • Marble Hornets: come for Slender Man, stay because you're too afraid to move.
  • The Slacktivist's blog: Come for Left Behind getting ripped a new one, stay for the political and philosophical posts. And Left Behind getting ripped a new one.
  • Cracked.com: Come for the gut-busting "top five" lists, stay for the even more gut-busting fan poster contests.

Western Animation

Real Life

  • College: Come for the additional education, stay for the shenanigans.
    • For some, it's the other way around.
    • And for yet others, it's Come because you can't get a job without a degree, stay because... you can't get a job without a degree.
    • Come for your parents, stay because you're getting your $30,000's worth.
    • Surely it's come to avoiding getting a real job and laze around for a few years, stay for the realisation of how much money you have spent on it.
    • Come for the food, stay for the wireless and free movies. (Honestly, a school that shows movies every week on a 232 inch screen between the time when they leave the theatre and the DVD release? Awesome.)
    • Come to get away from your family, stay because your friends there have become your new family.
  • The Gym: Come to lose weight, stay for the endorphin addiction.
    • or stay for the girls.
      • Or guys.
  • Alcohol: Come for the social acceptance, stay for the drunkenness.
  • Your Career: Come for the chance to work in your specialist field, stay for the paychecks that allow you to have a roof over your head, food in your belly, a place to rest your head, and clothes to cover your body.
  • The Internet: Come for the vast stores of news and information, stay for teh joeks! (Or teh pr0n, depending on your libido.) (Or the "innovative" spelling, if you've been online for any given length of time.)
    • Applies for tvtropes. A huge number of people found tvtropes searching for lolita and incest. The picture of someone coming to their stuff and then get sidetracked for hours just seems inherently funny.
  • Caffeine: Come for the quick pick-me-up it gives you, stay for the ability to ward off the waiting crash and burn.
  • Acetominophen: Come for its ability to treat a cold's aches and pains, stay for its ability to lower your fever.
  • Life: Come because you've been kind of forced into it, stay because...well there aren't any real alternatives.
  • California: Come for the earthquakes, stay for the wildfires.
  • Our Dumb World on Malawi: "Come for the food shortages, stay because you've died."
  • Sad example: North Korea (if you're Japanese or South Korean): Come because they invited you, stay because they won't let you leave.
  • Whatcom County, WA—come on vacation, stay on probation...
  • Dark chocolate. Come because it's delicious, stay because it's a natural source of antioxidants.
  • Movie posters and advertisements run on this trope. See Covers Always Lie for more.
  • Food: Come for the deliciousness, stay because your newly-gained fat won't let you do otherwise.
  • Sarcasm: Come to subtly vent about your life, stay because you've corrupted your innocence.
  • Ballet: Come for the dancing and story, stay for the Panty Shots.
    • Or vice versa (also applies to figure skating).
  • Getting a pet: Come for the Ridiculously Cute Critter (or Ugly Cute depending on the species), stay for the bonding and unconditional love.
  1. Or vice versa...
  2. And the Ho Yay, too...
  3. or to think dirty thoughts about the Pretty Boy/hot girl
  4. "I for one am starting to get bored, and boredom is something up with which I will not put!"