Orphaned/Sandbox/Page Restoration Petitions

This is a list of pages were cut under the policy change, but at least one editor believes the page should be restored.

A list of works that weren't cut, but possibly should be, is here. A full list of the cuts is here.


 * Nine Songs: Full of explicit sex, but generally agreed not to be porn, and has provoked at least one critical essay (which I unfortunately can't find) explaining why it (along with Shortbus, which I think we still have a page for) shouldn't be condemned for having sex in it. (That essay instead said that they should be considered godawful movies, but we're in the business of documenting the awful as well as the good, right?)
 * Anatomy of Hell, since Breillat's other works are here, and the only difference in content between those and AoH is that AoH is a really stupid movie and is slightly less obscure.
 * Bliss Stage: Sex is not required for play, let alone explicit sex. It's a game system, so the work itself contains no sex, underage or otherwise. Only game sessions can have sex, and as mentioned, it is optional. The official game rules.
 * Breaking The Waves (note: I don't know if this was the only von Trier movie to NOT have a page, or if it got deleted, which is strange because it's one of his tamest works.)
 * Breast Sponge -- not inherently a porn trope, and was cut while the relevant TRS thread is still ongoing.
 * Caligula should probably be reinstated, despite being graphically sexual and violent, has an incredible production history that troubled barely begins to describe, claims the involvement of many prominent actors and actresses, and was supposed to be a very serious look at how power corrupts.
 * Collar Six: This was part of Glider Guy's cutlisting spree and it was cut right after it was posted to the review thread. The cut reason given misrepresented the work. It involves an Alternate Universe with a BSDM based Blue and Orange Morality and a complex non-sex plot arc. The incident mentioned with the aphrodisiac was between the BDSM equivalent of a married couple. There is fetish aplenty so it may not pass review, but it should BE reviewed.
 * Creepy Sexy: Combining the Uncanny Valley with sexual imagery to disturb or unsettle the audience is enough of a well-established concept in fiction to deserve a trope page. Fast Eddie cut it with the reason "subjective as hell, solicits creepy stuff", but we could still have the trope description with No Examples Please.
 * The Erotic Mind Control Story Archive: Bills itself, obviously, as a porn site, but if memory serves there are stories in which the plot almost overwhelms the porn.
 * Fan Fic/Hooker Verse and its subpages. Despite the name and premise, not porn in the slightest. The sex between the characters is usually quick and desperate, while the client sex is usually quick and gross, and both concentrate on the feelings than explicit descriptions. To put it simply, it's a depiction of screwed up people trying desperately to either get out of their life or at least survive. (Plus, even the TGWTG team have enjoyed it, if find it a bit too despairing.)
 * Manga/Ichinensei Ni Nacchattara: It's a Widget Series of the Slice of Life genre that thrives on silliness. While nudity may pop up now and then, the whole thing is generally too silly to be considered even remotely sexual.
 * Ken Park: Critics are split about 50-50 as to whether it's porn or art. We might as well document the controversy, although it probably shouldn't have a YMMV page.
 * Kite: Similar to Mezzo Forte, for the longest time the only version you could find was the censored version without the sex scenes, and it really didn't take away much to not have them. Said sex scenes are also generally of the Fan Disservice variety. See also this post.
 * Living With Monster Girl: It was deleted for being hentai. It has more than enough plot and characterization to qualify as plot with porn. Despite the premise, it's Sweet Dreams Fuel and what ever porn it does have is not overly graphic. Lastly, there is no pedo anywhere in the work.
 * Manga/Lotte No Omocha: While the synopsis may turn off those who don't read past it, the manga is much Better Than It Sounds -- a pretty clean light-hearted comedy, and completely different from what it may seem from the synopsis. Despite the Audience-Alienating Premise, the work depicts no explicit sex acts whatsoever. At its core, it is a heartwarming story with themes of family with a respectable father as a protagonist. The anime is officially licensed in the US by Crunchyroll and watchable there.
 * Naughty Tentacles: Yes, I am aware that this trope is the one that set off the incident. However, this does not change the fact that it is, indeed, a trope. This can be evidenced by it being parodied in at least a few manga & anime, as it would not be known enough to play with otherwise, IMO. While the examples themselves most likely need to go (preferably move them to the Fetish Fuel Wiki or something similar), the trope itself can stay with a little rewording. Make the discussion cold, clinical, not arousing in any way whatsoever. Possibly mention the historic reason for it, or link to some other page that does so ("For more information, see..."). Mention that while it is normally only seen in hentai, it can sometimes make guest appearances in other work, and most likely led to the creation of the safe-for-work Tentacle Rope trope. While I am partially motivated by, well, the fact that it's kinda hot, the fact remains that it is a trope that can stand on its own with a little push in the right direction. And now my spear and I depart into the night, lost unto the mists of time.
 * Otoko no Ko wa Meido Fuku ga Osuki: Was one of the few cut things that was listed as "No reason" for being cut. Plot is a comedy involves a family-run maid cafe run by young boys crossdressing up as girls, willingly or not. It also involves said young boys dressed in fanservicey outfits designed for girls...which I'm guessing probably falls under Shotacon in most people's definition. Intent of the fanservicey outfits seems to be mostly about lampshading or even mock the maid cafe culture and how it exploits the sexuality of their waitresses and the general atmosphere to attract customers.
 * Pokegirls, for reasons listed in this forum post.
 * Salo Or The 120 Days Of Sodom, because of its critical significance - it has been listed as one of the greatest horror films of all time by Time Out Film Magazine, in addition to being a Criterion Collection selection. Also, we at one time had an entry for the de Sade book it was based on.
 * Manga/Under Grand Hotel: Deleted because it was (inappropriately) on the hentai index. This is action/romance, with some fairly explicit erotic content, but in line with others of its genre (which is Boys Love Genre, not hentai). Admittedly a dark work (it was inspired by Oz); there's more violent/disturbing content than sex. All characters are adult.
 * Virgin Night is usually classified as hentai, but it's closer to romance with sex in it. In general, works by Tanaka Yutaka are less sexually explicit not just than most hentai, but than the more extreme Ecchi. One of his other works, My Lovely Ghost Kana, is about as graphic but did not get cut.

Cut Fanfic Rec Petitions

 * Paint with All the Colors of the Cosmos was nuked from That Guy With the Glasses for being porn. I can safely say that it's not. It's from the point of view of an anthropomorphic eyeliner wanting to take over the world by attaching itself to pretty internet reviewers. So basically, epic crack. The only sex stuff is a few references to looking like a hooker, slapping and then making out. And if you've seen the shows of The Nostalgia Critic and The Nostalgia Chick, you'll know that's pretty tame for them.