Thread:Forum:Wiki Talk/How do we avoid "Dare You Enter my Magical Realm" syndrome when discussing porn?/reply

I don't think the breast expansion page is that bad. It's just that the subject matter is inherently sexualized.

We could remove some details (we have separate listings for separate stories in the breast expansion archive--that could lead to thousands of entries if we don't make it clear that no more new entries should be added) but I don't think that just removing such things has a snowball's chance in HFIL of preventing us from being criticized. We could have a rule "don't list porn tropes for porn series" or "don't list porn tropes for web original/fanfic". That might make the pages better, but again, that's not going to prevent criticism (and most of the page is not web original or fanfic--the BEA stuff is a small portion of the whole page). I was tempted to just write "there's nothing we can do other than have good human moderators", but again, the best moderators in the world really won't prevent criticism either.

My best idea is to go to some of the places where we're criticized for this and ask "Okay, what should we do about it". See if they can come up with something other than just removing anything that might be sexual.