Orphaned/Sandbox/Pages Pending for Perusal by P 5

A list of uncut works that should be reviewed by the P5 for being against the new content policy or being borderline. Note that you may also post here if you think a page only needs to be cleaned rather than just cut.

You are also free to add a short defense and edit any defenses already on here. You are not free to argue incessantly on this page, so one defense per petition please. Also, no anti-defenses. Thank you.

The page for appealing works that have already been cut from the wiki is here.

Currently in review

 * Atlach=Nacha: H-game with lesbian rape.
 * Defense: Needs scrubbed of pictures, troping edited for content/neutrality, then locked.

General works

 * Addergoole: page is pretty sparse (little more than a bare trope list), but does contain a lot of sex tropes.
 * Defense: While there are sex tropes involved, the story itself is not pornographic & the sex is a small part of a very large story
 * Alien from the Darkness: Hentai
 * Bakemonogatari: Sexualization of several underage female characters.
 * Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai: Maria and Kobato are very much underage.
 * The Brown Bunny: Plot With Porn, but the only explicit scene is a blowjob scene.
 * Defense: That really is the only explicit scene, and it's brief. Based from external sources, the act was also consensual among both actors (although still controversial). The overall theme relates more to
 * Cannibal Ferox, Cannibal Holocaust: Gorn that averts No Animals Were Harmed
 * Cats N Cameras: page says "NC-17 rated" and that it has "copious amounts of Fanservice."
 * Defense: "but has more plot that sex. It's just that when sex happens they don't skip past it."
 * Chester 5000 XYV: identified as erotic and explicitly sexual.
 * Defense: "Erotic, but deep and focuses more on showing how relationships develop and love than just on sex. Might qualify is borderline erotica, but wouldn't count as porn."
 * Chimneyspeak: Gory violence, nudity, non-explicit sex, page has links to artist's other NSFW (and much more porny) works. Child prostitution is referenced but not shown, and is a Berserk Button of one of the main protagonists.
 * Proposal: Cut all direct links, lock page.
 * Chintsubu: Described as "a manga about boys with talking penises", contains sexual humor involving possibly-underaged characters. The person submitting it does not know how explicit the manga actually is but still feels that it should be looked over. Context: Smutty gag comedy, characters are identified as second- and third-year high school (~16-18), but one is young-looking enough that the author feels the need to add a little "note: high school student" label during his first sex scene.
 * Chugworth Academy: stub article, but calls it a "sexist comic" and alludes to "sexual exploits."
 * Curvy: "too NSFW to link"; "Everyone Has Lots of Sex".
 * Defense: "Very NSFW, but very plot heavy with a lot of wacky hijinks. Largely a story about adventures in dimension travel. Plot with Porn. Biggest issue is that several of the characters don't seem to wear clothes."
 * Batman In the Bowels of Hell: Porn with bare threads of plot
 * Corruption Of Champions: Sex and fetish transformation game. The premise seems to involve rape a lot.
 * Dragon Crisis: Rose is definitely underage, and is repeatedly shown undressed and generally in a sexualized fashion.
 * Drawn To Bondage: Porn Without Plot.
 * Doki Doki Majo Shinpan: Excuse Plot with Porn.
 * Defence: It's actually Ecchi rather than explicit porn. It was rated C for ages 15+.
 * Dumbledores Army and The Year of Darkness: Rape as Drama twice
 * Defense: As with many of these entries, the rape is not the main focus of the fic
 * Elle, and all the others: "The redhead pushes him back into the house and proceeds to magically paralyze him so she can check out the size of his penis. Oral sex ensues." Yeah, that sounds like the sort of thing we're looking to get rid of.
 * Futari Ecchi: Explicit sex, though it should be mentioned that it is licensed.
 * Defense: Slice of Life about a married couple counts as plot since there is plenty of character development for the characters involved. Intended to be educational, contains charts and graphs about surveys taken about the people of japan and relationships and sex.
 * Grant: Said to have explicit content, but you have to register to see it. Don't know if that sort of thing is against our guidelines.
 * Defense: Only R-rated, and has no porn at all. It just requires registration to see, because that's how Fur Affinity works if anything's greater than PG-13. There is no actual porn in the story.
 * Hanamachi Monogatari: Shotacon H-game
 * HATEFARM: "somewhat randomly NSFW due to nudity or violence"; "relies frequently on sex or gross-out humor". Again, I'm not sure if sexual humor (as opposed to explicit sex played for titillation) is a no-no.
 * Hidan no Aria: Very fanservicey, and Aria looks like a middle schooler.
 * High School DxD: porn-based plot about a high-school guy who becomes a sex-demon and starts building his own harem. His powers include being able to disintegrate people's clothes.
 * Defense:
 * Huckleberry Ann: Explicit porn.
 * The Idolmaster: Several underaged characters depicted in sexualized fashion.
 * Defense: No actual sex is shown
 * Intense!: Porn Without Plot Dragonball Z parody.
 * Inu X Boku SS: Ririchiyo is totally pedobait.
 * I Spit on Your Grave: Infamous exploitation film about rape.
 * Defense: Classic movie, deals with mostly getting revenge on the people who wronged the main character.
 * IT: There's one particularly infamous scene where a bunch of underage kids have sex. The trope page mentions that they are so underage that it's highly unlikely that they could have even performed the sexual acts they're said to perform in the book.
 * Defense: This appears to be another test case of sorts of what is going to pass by this council, as IT is very much a legitimate work in the Stephen King collection of horror novels.
 * Jay Naylor: furry porn artist of several porn works on the wiki, including porn side stories for Better Days and Fall Of Little Red Riding Hood (possibly; nominator isn't certain if porn artists/authors are excluded under new guidelines).
 * Also writes non-Porn including the main Better Days series. Page can be rewritten entirely about his other work.
 * Jiz: Gag Dub of Jem and The Holograms, intentionally NSFW and Crosses the Line Twice, very controversial material, much sexual.
 * Defense: Seems to be more about Black Humor and snark than about titillation or arousal per se. I think it's defensible in the way that South Park, Family Guy, and, if we choose to keep it, Ax Cx are, but it, like South Park and Ax Cx, definitely needs a cleaning, removal of links to it, and in its individual case, possibly to be made into a locked stub article.
 * Kamidori Alchemy Meister: "Not quite sure about this one. This is a Visual Novel/Turn Based Strategy H-game hybrid. A... crafted plot is there, but its purpose for existing borders on being an Excuse Plot for a H-centric game due to the abundance/frequency of those scenes appearing at awkward moments where you'd expect it to focus on story or where nothing particular is going on at all."
 * Defense: Plot is allegedly enough to not be an Excuse Plot. Furthermore, the sex scenes don't appear until the latter half of the game.
 * Kamisama Dolls: The main character's younger sister Utao is very underage, portrayed in a sexual light, and lusts for her brother.
 * Kichiku Megane: Explicitly pornographic BL game.
 * The game has a considerable amount of fairly explicit (full-body nudity but no genitalia) and often abusive sex, but the plot routes are primarily relationship dramas. Like most visual novels it's light on interactivity and most of the "action" is talking-heads rather than doing badass things, but playtime is largely about conversations with the love interest, finding out about their backstories, and your internal monologue. It's admittedly quite dark; the plots usually start with some kind of Non Con and most of the bad ends feature murder.
 * Kore wa Zombie Desu ka?: Haruna and Eu are definitely pedobait.
 * Legolas By Laura: Lolicon, according to the trope page (main character is 10).
 * Defense(?): The most explicit this gets is "and then one of the Orcs striped her and then he raped her". Not erotic in any way.
 * Litchi Hikari Club: Graphic horror manga legally licensed in English, starring a depraved gang of junior-high boys (age not specified, junior high = approx 12-14). There are two brief but explicit sexual acts between the boys, and a brief view of a younger girl who has been assaulted with a pice of piping in a way I don't particularly want to describe, all played for shock value. (Also lots and lots of gory violence.)
 * Lovemagic: described as an "adult webcomic" and "very NSFW"; apparently also contains Naughty Tentacles prominently in one section.
 * Lucky Dog 1: Explicitly pornographic BL game.
 * Our page on the matter says it's Plot With Porn. May need a closer look.
 * Marquis de Sade: Page describing the infamous pornographer, with a list of tropes for his (entirely pornographic) works. Sade is considered to be an important historical and literary figure, and appears as a character in many works, including a substantial number of non-pornographic ones, so the page should be reviewed rather than cut.
 * The Mating Frenzy: Plotless porn.
 * Mitsudomoe: Lolicon and Shotacon. According to the trope page, the characters (including the kindergarden students) are perverted, and are explicitly referred to as such in the anime/manga.
 * Defense: The little kids aren't remotely sexualized in design and are purely Puni Plush. Badly drawn Puni Plush dare I say. There are plenty of verbal sexual jokes made by the kids, but that's it.
 * Moon Over June: page describes it as having lots of sexual content
 * Morenatsu: Explicitly pornographic BL game with one borderline shotacon love interest.
 * Defense: Plot With Porn. We can't discriminate against furry Bara porn.
 * Nana to Kaoru: a softcore porn Ecchi series about underage schoolkids practicing BDSM. No sex, but still no purpose other than wank material.
 * Defense: I quote from the YMMV page, "The only major research failure with the series is the lack of safewords, other than that it's pretty much been a textbook lesson in a wholesome BDSM relationship." In other words, it's a typical romance story with added BDSM.
 * Natsuiro Kiseki: The main cast are all middle schoolers, and one of them is shown in her underwear for a significant chunk of an episode.
 * Narutaru: Both the anime and manga involve the violent rape of a twelve-year-old girl by a group of classmates, and that same girl using a superpowered monster to rape the group's leader in the same way. The manga involves the twelve-year-old protagonist having sex with another character (the person submitting this is not sure about their age) and becoming pregnant.
 * Defense: Both the anime and 8 volumes out of 12 were licensed and published in the US, so they have met certain minimal standards to avoid "pedophile pandering". That includes the rape scenes (albeit toned down). The mentioned scenes (and any other similar) are all played for drama or straight out horror, and are far from making up the bulk of the story. The sex scene mentioned above is not graphic and mostly implied. While Mohiro Kitoh is a horrible bastard for what he does to his characters, most of the supposed sexual stuff he does is mostly implied and/or fades to black within a matter of panels, so it really isn't something that should be considered for deleting and/or censoring.
 * Naruto Veangance Revelaitons: Disturbing and has explicit sex.
 * Neo Armageddon Evangelist Looks to be a porn fic centered around rape as a Deus Sex Machina, plus it seems some characters are under 16 when raped. Also has Naughty Tentacles involved. The recommendation for this fic was removed for the aforementioned reasons when the "no Lemon fics w/under-16 characters" was introduced.
 * NSFW Comix: Apparently so NSFW that the page forbids links; trope list contains many sexual tropes, and non-sexual ones with sexual examples (e.g. I Ate What? references "jacking off into the food").
 * Nyarko San: Lots of fanservice, and the main female characters are questionably of age at best (true identity as Lovecraftian horrors aside).
 * Defense: The fanservice is fairly non explicit, and no genitals are shown. The art style is largely responsible for why the characters look young (they are for all intents an purposes at least high school age but look younger much like in Lucky Star). The main focus is on parodying the Cthulhu Mythos, not for perversion.
 * Paint the Town: Grotesque porn involving at least one underage character.
 * Paladin of Shadows: Lolicon elements. The writeup by Hradzka, for example, discusses the protagonist paying for a 15-year old prostitute for the day, then repeatedly 'brutalizing' her. There's heavy additional pornographic content.
 * Defense: There are no "Lolicon elements", for starters, as the term is used on TV Tropes; Mike isn't treated as "ultimately harmless" or "a humorous figure", but is a Jerkass who knows he's deeply flawed and tries to do good even if by unconventional means, a la Dexter. While there are multiple sex scenes (including the aforementioned 15 year old prostitute he brutalized, and then gave extra money for putting up with his treatment; even then what he did isn't presented as a good thing), they're not the focus of the series, nor are they a majority of the work in spite of the "gets lots of pussy" from the series' TVT description. The books are available from B&N, Amazon, and other general public book sellers without any special restrictions.
 * Panty and Stocking With Garterbelt: Explicit on-screen sex, fanservice, constant swear words, Refuge in Audacity. A page clean-up effort is being undertaken to deal with how vulgar our page on the show has become.
 * Defense: The series is ultimately an action-comedy. Despite there being on-screen sex, it is brief and nothing of detail is shown.
 * Papa no Iukoto o Kikinasai!: Main character takes in his underage nieces. Fanservice ensues.
 * Papa to Kiss in the Dark: Originally a shoujo-targeted Boys Love Genre Light Novel series, but the novels are not available in English, so Western fans know it from the OVAs, which are legally licensed in English. The main character is a high-school freshman (age not specified but Japanese freshman = probably about 15) who ends up in a relationship with his adoptive father, who is actually his uncle. There is some very tame on-screen sex. The execution is typical light-angst teen romance but the premise probably justifies a look. (Note that although some Western fans consider it shotacon because of the main character's young-looking design, it is not labelled or marketed as such in Japan.)
 * Patalliro: 10 year old main character groping people and using sexual innuendo, as well as engaging in Selfcest.
 * Defense: Entirely Played for Laughs in an entirely unrealistic comedy Widget Series, manga is probably around a PG-13/Older Teen, and is marketed toward a Shoujo or Shounen demographic depending on whom you ask, though it has a fairly large Periphery Demographic in Japan. Nominating as a test case for surrealism and comedy being a defense.
 * Peter Is the Wolf: Explicit pornography.
 * Note: while there is a SFW version, the trope page mentions that several of the 'SFW' pages are just like the NSFW ones, only with the nipples redacted. It's still explicit porn, just with very minor tweaks.
 * Defense: If it has a SFW version, then the original was probably Plot With Porn. We shouldn't cut something just because it has Furry
 * RE-TAKE: Explicit underage sex, pregnancy, and marriage. There is a "all-ages" version.
 * Defense: As mention, there are versions that omit the sex with no repercussion to the plot.
 * Defense/Proposal: Plot With Porn, and aforementioned "all-ages" version - suggest rewriting to only reference the latter version and locking.
 * Ro-Kyu-Bu!: Loads of fanservice from the elementary school girl cast.
 * Ryofukochan: Page says it's lolicon
 * Seikon no Qwaser: Borderline hentai with Audience-Alienating Premise (namely, that magic powers in this universe are powered by sucking on womens' breasts).
 * Defence: No sex at all, a heavily censored TV version is available that puts Censor Bars over any nudity and heavy on the plot.
 * Sensitive Pornograph: Page suggests explicit sex and perhaps porn.
 * Sentimental Shooting: Porn Without Plot H-Game SHMUP.
 * Shiniez: BDSM fetish comic; sounds like at least partially Porn Without Plot ("started life as a series of unconnected fetish drawings featuring the same two characters").
 * Defense: Plot involves a developing romance between two women trying out the BDSM lifestyle for the first time. The sex stuff, though enough to render the comic NSFW and warrant a Mature Content filter, isn't too explicit (Deviant ART, where the comic is posted, does not allow explicitness when it comes to sexual stuff).
 * Shredded Moose: Described on its page as having gratuitous sex and Gorn. Also, the comic itself apparently no longer exists, so why commemorate it with a page here?
 * Sono Hanabira ni Kuchizuke wo: Explicitly pornographic Yuri game involving possibly-underage characters. One entry in the series is explicitly stated to contain lolicon.
 * Defense: Plot With Porn. It's also a bit strict to cut the whole franchise page out because one game had lolicon elements. I suppose we can single that one out for deletion, or at the very least mention the bare details about said content and have it left at that.
 * Silver Chaos: Explicitly pornographic BL game with one underage love interest.
 * South Park: To be fair, it does need cleaning.
 * Defense: A clean-up thread in Special Efforts is underway.
 * Starfighter: page says "NSFW for graphic sex, but has a SFW filter page."— how do we handle these sorts of things?
 * Sugar's Delight: Porn Without Plot girl love game.
 * Defense: Needs scrubbed of pictures, troping edited for content/neutrality, then locked.
 * Sundome: Explicit pornography. The plot is a group of virgins trying to fend off the advances of a group of people who attempt to use the first group's fetishes to make them lose their virginity.
 * Tales Of Gnosis College: identified as "adults-only" and containing bizarre "sexperiments".
 * Tales of MU: Plot driven largely by porn after the first few chapters. One of the main characters is a nymph that believes clothes are against her religion and feeds off of sex; another is a dark elf for whom nudity (and, IIRC, sex itself) is a sacred ritual. A third is a necrophiliac. There's also vore (the secretary, the mermaids).
 * Defense: This, frankly, is a poorly-written description. Plot With Porn at most, and sexually-themed chapters become much less frequent as it progresses. Necromancy is referenced but IIRC there is no necrophilia, and the vore element is overstated. There is a underage sex element, but it is backstory for a character that is not in the main story, has not been described other than the fact that it happened, and is not at all intended to be titillating (the trope page gives more detailed explanations).
 * Tottemo Pheromone: Explicitly pornographic H-Game.

My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic Fan Fiction

 * Romance Reports: Plot With Porn that is explicit. It should be noted that it is subject to It Gets Better.
 * The Spiderses: Troll Fic Porn Without Plot spider sex.
 * Defense: The sex scene is hardly the focus of the plot, and it is intended to be Narmy as opposed to disgusting or titillating. Equestria Daily, which normally refuses to post fanfics with explicit content, featured this story prominently.