Thread:Forum:Wiki Talk/YMMV integration/reply (2)

Nerdanel, I definitely sympathize with you, but I also agree with QuestionableSanity that the fan opinions belong on the YMMV pages. However, I can agree that the Happiness is Mandatory nonsense on TV Tropes is foolish, so if you want to leave a review that is critical of a work, you can do so on our review pages without fear.

Another reasons why YMMV Tropes are on a subpage is for a reason on TVT I can agree with: it prevents fans having edit wars on the main pages, and let's face it, on tropes guaranteed to cause fans to get into heated arguments, this is inevitable, so they do serve a useful purpose in minimizing disruptions on the wiki.

However, I do support your position on being honest, and if something is objectively bad, YMMV Trope or not, then feel free to state that, as we have no Happiness is Mandatory policies here.